Mike Celizic

Get over the notion that Roger Clemens deserved his eighth Cy Young Award on the basis that he had the lowest ERA in 10 years and is as old as the Rocky Mountains and equally as admired.

The Cy Young Award goes to the best pitcher, not the most popular, not the one with the best human-interest sidebar nor the one who stands to get the most endorsement deals for hanging up another plaque. And as much as I found what Houston Astros' Clemens did last season beyond belief, he wasn’t the National League’s best pitcher.

That person would be Chris Carpenter, the St. Louis Cardinals ace who blossomed after seven years of underachievement into a starter who went 21-5 with a 2.83 ERA, seven complete games and four shutouts.

And if it’s not Carpenter, it’s Dontrelle Willis of the Florida Marlins, the 2003 Rookie of the Year who rebounded this season after a sophomore slump to lead the NL in wins with 22.

But it’s not Clemens.

I’ll admit the arguments for Clemens are attractive, even if they’re not compelling. He rang up 1.87 ERA, which is the lowest since Greg Maddux fashioned a 1.63 ERA for the Atlanta Braves in 1995, when umpires were still giving him three or four inches outside the black on both sides of home plate. Clemens pitched 211.1 innings and had 185 strikeouts.

Forty-three-year-old guys don’t put up numbers like that. Heck, 23-year-olds don’t, either. And if the Cy were given to the best age-adjusted performance or the most impressive performance by a guy who uses a walker to get to the team bus, Clemens would be your man.

Slide show   Week in Sports Pictures A Flyin’ Lion, an onrushing Tide, hard hoops fouls and more. more photos

But there’s a little problem with wins; Clemens had just 13 of them against eight defeats. His defenders will say quite accurately that the Rocket got less support from the Astros than Anna Nicole Smith would get from a Kleenex bra. They were shut out in seven of his starts, five of which ended in 1-0 scores, and handed him just 18 runs total in his first 11 starts.

If Clemens were still pitching for the New York Yankees, he would have won 20, but if a squirrel had longer ears and hind legs and a little powder-puff tail, it would be a rabbit. The game isn’t about ifs, it’s about numbers.

MORE FROM BASEBALL

Baseball Section Front

Baseball won't be the same without 'The Boss' End of an era: The Boss' reign is officially over Yanks' offer to Sabathia won't stay on table long Yankees' Mussina retires, with 270-153 record At Bat: The ripple effect of Mussina's retirement Open Mike: Mussina deserves to be in Hall of Fame Feds seek release of BALCO transcripts Boston's Matsuzaka says he'll play in WBC Expert: Cubs need to address power woes Opinion: Burnett the ultimate free agent gamble Baseball Section Front   Add Baseball headlines to your news reader: