A big ‘but’ arises in toilet-seat story

Man who sued over glue prank made similar allegation in past, official says

NBC VIDEO

Toilet-suit man on hot seat
Nov. 9: A man who claims he was glued to a toilet seat at a Colorado Home Depot is being questioned about his police record. KUSA-TV’s Ward Lucas reports.

MSNBC

NBC VIDEO

Home Depot bathroom suit
Nov. 7: Bob Dougherty and his lawyer, Mark Cohen, talk to MSNBC TV’s Chris Jansing about the incident.

MSNBC

Video: Life

More video

NYC unlikely home to winemaking
Oct. 7: With no vineyards in sight, Manhattan might seem like an unlikely spot. But the owner says that's the best part. WNBC's Cat Greenleaf reports.

'Nudism is about enjoying sun, air and body'

Bring home the bacon

Newman leaves legacy of hope

66-year-old sunken submarine discovered

Economy in Turmoil

What is your top concern about the economy? Vote and share your story. Click here to learn more and get involved.

NBC Field Notes

NBC News correspondents and producers across the U.S. shed light on the news of the day.

Photo features

Reuters	The Week in Pictures A bride goes fishing, while mini-Mahatma Gandhis compete on looks – just two of this week’s photo choices
AP	PhotoBlog View and discuss the pictures and issues that caught our eyes.

updated 4:21 p.m. ET Nov. 8, 2005

DENVER - A man who sued Home Depot last month claiming a prank left him glued to a toilet seat made a similar allegation about another restroom more than a year ago, an official told a newspaper.

Bob Dougherty’s lawsuit alleges employees at the store ignored his pleas for help on the day before Halloween 2003 because they thought he was kidding.

But Ron Trzepacz, former director of operations for the town of Nederland, where Dougherty lives, told the Rocky Mountain News in Tuesday’s editions that Dougherty told him in the summer of 2004 he was glued to a toilet seat in the town’s visitor center but pulled himself free.

Story continues below ↓

Trzepacz told the paper he inspected the bathroom and found “no indication that anything had been on the toilet seat.” No police report was filed, he said.

Dougherty’s lawyer, Mark Cohen, denied his client made such a claim and said Dougherty is willing to take a polygraph test.

“The allegation doesn’t make any sense,” Cohen told The Associated Press Tuesday.

Neither Trzepacz nor the Nederland town administrator immediately returned a call from the AP. Nederland is about 45 miles northwest of Denver.

Dougherty’s lawsuit, filed Oct. 28, said officials at the store in Louisville called for an ambulance after he had been stuck for about 15 minutes. Paramedics unbolted the toilet seat, which separated from his skin, leaving abrasions, according to the suit.

Click for related content

The lawsuit also said Dougherty was recovering from heart bypass surgery and thought he was having a heart attack when he got stuck.

The lawsuit claims he suffered pain, humiliation and financial loss. It seeks $3 million.