Sen. Brownback is key to nominee Miers’ fate

Bush showing the white flag?
But other GOP senators remained guarded in their reactions.

Emerging from the Republican senators’ weekly policy meeting Wednesday afternoon, Sen. John Thune, R-S.D. told reporters that grassroots conservatives were asking why Bush would “show the white flag when having a fight would really energize and motivate our supporters? And especially if you look at the politics of 2006, I think our folks were really ready for a fight. I think a Left v. Right fight is something that helps us. I think an internecine Right v. Less Right fight is something that doesn’t help us.”

That said, Thune added “a lot of folks are giving him (Bush) the benefit of the doubt and I think we have to do that until we hear more from her” during the Judiciary Committee hearings and in her one-on-one meetings.

“For conservatives out there, she is going to have to be very forthcoming in front of the committee to give them the confidence they need that she truly is going to be a judge in the mold of (Justice Antonin) Scalia and (Justice Clarence) Thomas,” he added.

Thune indicated some conservatives were still bewildered by the president’s nomination, given the large pool of highly accomplished conservative judges and scholars such as Luttig whom Bush — and Miers as head of his judicial selection team — chose to forego.

“Everybody would like to see a known commodity and there were a whole bunch of them on the bench that a lot of folks were saying, ‘Well, why wasn’t it a Luttig or a Priscilla Owen or Janice Rogers Brown, somebody that we know?” Thune said.

Brown serves on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

'A lot of anxiety and uncertainty'
“Conservatives see this (nomination) as having enormous stakes, that’s why there’s a lot of anxiety and uncertainty as to where she’s really going to come down,” Thune said.

Looking to the Judiciary committee’s confirmation hearings on Miers, Thune said “she’s going to have to give a very good insight into her judicial philosophy, whether she’s an originalist, whether she’d exercise judicial restraint. Those hearings are going to be enormously important.”

From the other side of the political spectrum, Democrats and liberal groups active in judicial nominations said they still knew too little about Miers.

“I know zero about her,” said Sen. Joe Biden, D-Del. “This woman does not appear to be like Sandra Day O’Connor but we’ll see — or maybe we won’t see. They may do the stonewall thing like they did with Roberts.”

If the Senate voted down Miers, could Bush send the Senate another nominee more conservative than Miers?

“It’s hard to say the next one would be worse when we know so little about Miers,” said Nan Aron, president of the liberal Alliance for Justice. “President Bush is asking a lot of the American people — maybe too much — to take on his faith his judgment that she’s qualified.”

Trying to build support for Miers was former Republican National Committee chairman Ed Gillespie, who met with GOP senators Wednesday.

“The more people on the conservative side of the spectrum know about her, the stronger her support will get,” Gillespie told reporters.

“The nomination is in strong shape,” he said. “I’ve not heard anyone speculate that she’s not likely to be confirmed.”

MORE FROM THE CHANGING COURT

The Changing Court Section Front

On first case, Alito splits with right Alito sworn in as Supreme Court justice Alito lends touch of drama to State of Union Analysis: Why Bush won the Alito fight The Changing Court Section Front   Add The Changing Court headlines to your news reader: