Benefit concert goes from great to ‘wow’

Sept. 2 | 8 p.m., ET

5:00: These celebrity concerts aren't always the greatest things to watch, but with so many New Orleans music figures involved, I bet they make a CD of the performances and sell it to help raise money.

5:02: Opening with Harry Connick Jr. and Wynton Marsalis playing the horn is a great idea. As far as I'm concerned, this should be the entire concert.

5:05: Hilary Swank's the first celebrity presenter. She tells us the hurricane devastated an area the size of Kansas, 90 percent of the structures on the Gulf Coast have been obliterated and still 1 million people are homeless after the storm.

I don't care how often I read it or hear, those figures still devastate me.

5:09: Solid piece on what the hurricane did to New Orleans. We'll see more of that.

5:10: Tim McGraw follows as the second musical act. He's a guy I don't doubt would donate as much time and money to the area as needed. Sounds pretty good, too.

5:11: Just got an e-mail saying that the guitar MSNBC.com is auctioning off will be signed by Tim McGraw in a few minutes. I wonder if people can really get into an auction in a setting like this. Can someone get worked up over an item or are you mostly just donating money without much thought to what you're bidding on? Still, I'll be interested to see how much the guitar goes for.

5:13: Now Richard Gere, telling us how the city simply doesn't have any water. Talk about something a city on the water — set below sea level — takes for granted. Who ever really thinks they'll run out of water? I know indoor plumbing ranks pretty high up on the list of things I take for granted.

5:14: Nice move with Tim going for an upbeat song. I always worry that these charity concerts will be so downcast and sad that people won't watch. Is it wrong that there should be some kind of entertainment factor involved? People need to feel uplifted at some point.

5:15: I don't think I have any Tim McGraw in the CD collection, either. Seen him in concert, but no CDs. Not sure how that works out. "Something Like That" certainly is one you have an easy time grooving to.

5:17: And so the guitar auction starts. It feels like a plug for the Web site, but so it goes.

5:18: Eriq La Salle and Lindsay Lohan. How the pairings for these things get determined is beyond me.

5:19: From Faith Hill to another TV piece. Faith narrates this one.

5:20: I'll confess, this piece — all about how people were caught off guard by Katrina — hits home to me. After those hurricanes pounded Florida last year with minimal damage and with the other hurricanes that hit this year, I was to the point where it seemed like if a person just grits their teeth, takes a few precautions and stays indoors, it'll be OK.

Couldn't be much more wrong. Mother Nature, man. She does whatever she wants.

5:23: The worst part about blogging this thing is I can't hear the concert that well with all the keyboard noise and newsroom din. I'm hoping for the CD.

5:24: Glenn Close and John Goodman. Both in suit jackets and Goodman in a tie. Gere was wearing jeans and a Red Cross hat. What does a person wear to a fundraiser? Whatever you're comfortable in? Does the clothing people wear affect the donations? Who knows these things?

5:25: Love Aaron Neville.

A man that big with a voice that sweet defies all logic. Of course, Aaron must hear that kind of thing all time.

5:26: He's singing a song called "Louisiana 1927." (Originally told it was Louisiana Tribute.) Not sure it could be more apt to the event. All about the waters "trying to wash us away." Lovely song.

5:28: New York Gov. George Pataki? Normally, that kind of appearance would smack of political nonsense, since Pataki is a big-time Republican. But since he's presenting a check for $2.5 million, I'd say this is on the level. A "thank you" from New York, in remembrance of 9/11.

5:30: This piece is done by MSNBC's Joe Scarborough. I could do without him presenting himself in the piece so much, but I guess you have to brand it somehow. Saw a similar piece by CNN's Anderson Cooper today where he tried to talk to people who lost their homes and couldn't quite compose himself. The need to insert oneself into a piece seems like an odd criticism from someone blogging a charity concert, but it just strikes me as odd.

Would a typical reporter insert himself into a story about hurricane victims?

Print this Email this Blog this  IM this

MORE FROM A CONCERT FOR HURRICANE RELIEF

A Concert for Hurricane Relief Section Front

Stars become ‘One’ with Katrina victims Blogging ‘Shelter from the Storm’ Autographed guitar auctioned for $30,900 Video: Connick sings for survivors Celebs pledge money, time to relief efforts Stars shine in Katrina benefit Make your donations for hurricane relief Ventre: Celebrity helps in relief efforts Slide show: Massive devastation A Concert for Hurricane Relief Section Front   Add A Concert for Hurricane Relief headlines to your news reader: