The truth about celebrity sex tapes

The average moviegoer knows maybe four things about Colin Farrell: that he has appeared in films like “S.W.A.T.” and “Alexander,” that he’s Irish, that he likes to swear a lot in interviews, and that he talks a great deal about drinking and sex. And now, thanks to last week’s ruling in a lawsuit Farrell brought against his Playboy Playmate ex-lover — the source of contention being a sex tape the two made together a couple years ago — the public knows one more fact about the actor: he’s got a hell of a lawyer.

How good is Farrell’s attorney? So good, he was able to extend an injunction that prevents the Playmate in question, the alliterative beauty Nicole Narain, from marketing said tape by arguing that releasing it would do irreparable harm to the plain-spoken star’s career.

Telling a judge with a straight face that a sex tape will damage the career of a lusty celebrity like Farrell is not merely audacious, it’s the legal equivalent of arguing that up is down and black is white.

A sex tape might embarrass a celebrity. It might shed light on that celebrity’s bedroom habits. It might even reveal, contrary to what we in the public want to believe, that a given celebrity is not a tender and attentive lover. But the one thing a sex tape won’t do is put a dent in someone’s career.

The judge in this case obviously hasn’t been paying attention to the proliferation of steamy featurettes made by the rich and famous in the last few years. However brilliant a legal mind his honor possesses, he knows little about the real-world precedents.

The benefits of infamy
Take the most obvious example, the tape made by Paris Hilton and former paramour Rick Solomon. While it’s true that the ubiquitous heiress tried to have the X-rated video suppressed, it’s also true that her rank on the A-list did not drop in any measurable way after it was distributed over the internet and seen by countless web surfers.

Slideshow   Ooo la la! It’s Paris! The highs and lows of trés jolie media darling Paris Hilton’s life. more photos

Hilton continues to appear on red carpets. Glossy magazine covers continue to sport her face. Fans have not shunned the willowy blond, and movie producers continue to offer her bit parts in middling features. The demand for everything Paris remains undiminished, as demonstrated by the fact that a new season of “The Simple Life” is in the works.

Of course, Hilton is an amateur when compared to sex-tape pioneer Pam Anderson, whose videotaped romp with Tommy Lee appears to be the best-selling example of the genre. When it surfaced, the pornographic home movie caused a sensation by exposing Anderson’s most private moments with her drummer husband for all to see; what it didn’t do was impair the busty celeb’s ability to make a living.

Since then, Pam has done even more spreads for Playboy. She branched out into writing, authoring a thinly veiled tell-all book. Her most recent venture, the sitcom “Stacked,” has been picked up for a second season — which in today’s television terms makes it a stunning success. Granted, her relationship with Lee has gone through periodic ups and downs, but her earning power has remained constant.

Even the most scandalous of scandalous sex tapes doesn’t have the power to shorten a star’s time at the top of the heap. Just look at R. Kelly. The R&B singer is allegedly featured in a video which shows an adult male having sex with a girl who may not be of age. The musician was charged in 2002 with several counts of child pornography after the tape began circulating — a fact that didn’t stop almost all of his next six albums from becoming million-sellers. As a New York street vendor selling the video told MTV News, “[People] don't care about the girls ... they wanna see him.”

Oh sure, Leno and Letterman will make plenty of jokes about you if you release a sex tape. But doing so won’t actually set you back in Hollywood.

MORE FROM MOVIES

Movies Section Front

‘Avatar’ blasts off with $232 million worldwide Streep and Baldwin — not a ‘Complicated’ pair Downey brings action to ‘Sherlock Holmes’ ‘Nine’ women latest to bewitch and bewilder You’ll wish you didn’t ‘Hear About the Morgans’ Sarah Jessica Parker can’t wait for Christmas Jeff Bridges is Bad to the bone in ‘Crazy Heart’ Cameron aims for ‘Titanic’ results with ‘Avatar’ Clooney, Streep, Bullock earn SAG Award nods This was not the decision Lucas was looking for Movies Section Front   Add Movies headlines to your news reader: