Skip navigation

‘American Idol’ fans
debate this week's final

Vonzell missed, but Bo and Carrie
each have many supporters

SOLOMON
Many "American Idol" fans were sad to see Vonzell Solomon go.
Interactive
Simon says
Sometimes the best part of “American Idol” is the latest sly comment from acerbic judge Simon Cowell. Here are some of our favorites from this season.
‘American Idol’ video
  Ellen DeGeneres named new ‘Idol’ judge
Sept. 10: Comedian and talk show host Ellen DeGeneres is joining “American Idol” as the show’s fourth judge, taking Paula Abdul’s place. TODAY’s Natalie Morales reports.

msnbc.com
updated 2:36 p.m. ET May 21, 2005

Only two remain. Vonzell Solomon was sent home on the latest "American Idol," leaving rocker Bo Bice and country girl Carrie Underwood to duke it out for the title on next week's show.

Here are some of your thoughts on the latest show.

VONZELL SHOULD HAVE STAYED
“I strongly believe that Carrie should have gone home and not Vonzell. Vonzell is more versatile and would make a better “Idol” than Carrie. In the end, however, Bo in my view will be crowned the next American Idol.”    --Amoi

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

VONZELL WAS THE BEST
“I think that Vonzell was the best. Even though she was not a perfect singer, she always had me excited about what song she was going to sing. Her performances were always upbeat and wonderful, and her personality shines. I think Carrie is a great singer but her personality is not all there. I think Bo should win it all. Bo has an awesome stage presence and looks like a pro. Also no one of his genre has one before. It would be nice to see him win.”    --Lindsey

TOO MUCH R&B?
“I think that we don’t need another R&B, hip hop singer. We had enough with Ruben and Fantasia. We wanted something different. So I think that is why she got the boot. I really like Bo and Carrie, so I would be happy if either wins.”    --Erika

GOOSE BUMPS
“Carrie Underwood. Consistent. Tremendous. Unspoiled. I get goose bumps listening to her.”    --Liz

CARRIE DOESN’T WANT IT
“Bo should win no doubt. Not only because he is better but Carrie didn’t seem like she really wanted to win when asked by Seacrest. She had a ‘whatever’ attitude and said there was a lot to go back to at home. So, let’s let her go. Then again if Bo loses he can get on to making an album his way and not be tied down to the Idol contract. I’m torn but like Bo better.”    --Heather

QUIT RUNNING, BO
“I don’t see what is so great about Bo. He is a decent singer, but Carrie has proved that she can sing, whether it be country or otherwise. She has sung songs other than country, which were good performances, she can hit and sustain those powerful high notes, and she has stage presence other than Bo’s patented running around with the microphone stand.”    --Anonymous

BO IS MORE THAN A ROCKER
“Bo Bice. Finally a person who can show today’s youth that one can rock, yet still sing other genres of music. He should win based on his “bandless song” alone. He took our breath away.”    --Joan

SICKY-SWEET CARRIE
“I agree with the boot. [Vonzell is] not as good as Carrie and Bo. I think Bo Bice should win, he is a better singer, has better stage presence and is a lot prettier. I think Carrie should go over to the Nashville network and try out. She does not belong on American Idol and her sweetness is really kind of sickening to watch.”    --Dianna

DANCING QUEEN
“Bo is easily the next idol. Singing a capella was a big risk and he met it easily. Paula is a choreographer, so how come she doesn’t critique the way Carrie moves on stage. That should count for something as an American Idol.”    --Regina

BOTH ARE WINNERS
“I have been a die hard fan of Carrie, since the first time I heard her sing! I knew that she was destined to be a star. She is absolutely beautiful and has the most powerful voice I have heard in a long time. Vonzell’s voice is also amazing, but she just doesn’t seem to have that “special something” that I see in Carrie. She will no doubt have offers for record deals lined up before she even steps foot back home. Bo has grown tremendously throughout the competition and has really proven himself as a vocalist and performer. He has won the hearts of many---including myself. I think Carrie and Bo signify everything this competition should be about. They are both genuine, down to earth, and 100% themselves when they are on stage. They are both just as unique in their own sound and genera of music, so it is very difficult to say that one is more outstanding than the other. My vote will have to go to Carrie because she stole my heart from day one. However, if the title goes to Bo there will be no disappointment on my face. Either way, both of them are already stars!”     --Trista

GREAT SEASON
“I believe America was right. Vonzell is very good & will continue to sing. I also believe Bo will win, he has all the characteristics for the American Idol. Carrie will also go far. I believe this season has had the best singers of all the competitions. It has been a pleasure to watch.”    --Sharon

© 2009 msnbc.com Reprints

  MORE FROM AMERICAN IDOL  
  
Happy birthday, Simon, the best mean Brit ever
 
Add American Idol headlines to your news reader:
 

Sponsored links

Resource guide