Oil platforms may be used for fish farms

The Gulf could be just the place where such a framework is developed.  Oil and gas platforms function as barn-like bases: They're big enough to store feed, their deck winches and cranes can lift and drop pens in and out of the water and, if needed, fish farmers can spend the night onboard.

And unlike many in Florida and California, the people along the coasts of Louisiana and Texas by and large welcome the offshore industry and its array of spindly legged and blinking rigs and platforms.  "The Gulf has tremendous potential," said Granvil Treece, an aquaculture specialist at the Texas Sea Grant.  "There's been a logjam so far, and that's been because of permitting mostly."

There are an estimated 3,500 idle platforms in the Gulf — and each one of them could be a candidate for a new lease on life as a fish farm.

"The oil companies are looking for a way of leaving platforms in place and delaying the disassembly and expensive process of dismantling and removing a platform," said George Chamberlain, president of the St. Louis-based Global Aquaculture Alliance.  It costs about $2 million to bring a platform ashore, Treece said, but another option, the "Rigs-to-Reefs" program converting a platform into an artificial reef, costs about $800,000.  Chamberlain said the cost of production in fish farming continues to decline.

So far farming from the Gulf's platforms has only been experimental.  In the late 1980s and early 1990s, for example, Occidental Petroleum Corp. teamed up with Texas Sea Grant scientists to grow redfish.  Feeding the penned fish brought out some ingenious ideas and presented some problems.

Project officials learned computers could be used to open feed gates.  With so many platforms far out in the Gulf a boat can't go out every day to unload fish feed as farmers do with salmon in the fjords of Scandinavia and North America.

"We dumped feed amounts in depending on how many fish were in the pens and what weight we wanted to grow them to," said Russell Miget, a Texas Sea Grant fisheries specialist who worked on the project.

Severe storms damaged some pens and fish got out.  And Treece said studies show that the ocean-raised redfish worked out to cost a whopping $22 a pound, whereas redfish sold for $3.50 a pound at market.  Also, just to run the platform's navigational lights and fight off corrosion cost about $50,000 a year, he said.

Miget remembered standing on a platform with an Occidental representative contemplating the future of fish farming. Responding to a question, Miget estimated that in ideal conditions, the platform could gross $6 million a year.  "The Occidental employee turned to me and said: 'We produce $6 million in gas every month off this platform,'" Miget said. "That put it in perspective."

Pro and con
While advocates believe it could work and be profitable, it's less sure whether any legislation Bush proposes will get the support of environmentalists.

Critics worry about turning the nation's oceans into the equivalent of ugly, dirty feedlots _ but for fish instead of cattle.   "It's much like chickens or hogs or other confined feeding operations on land and putting them in the ocean," said Roger Rufe, president of The Ocean Conservancy. "There are considerable issues with that, pollution issues."

Not to worry, Treece said, who believes the Gulf's strong currents "should take care of that," he said. "The solution to pollution is dilution, and that's what you got out here — lots of dilution."

"We've found environmental impacts to be relatively minor," Rubino said. "You don't want to crowd these together and stick them on top of coral reefs."  He added: "This is a big coastline. We're not needing a lot of space."

Critics also question whether the government should designate sections of the ocean for farming and, in effect, privatize a public resource.

Another concern: Hatchery-raised fish could be put out in open-water farms, escape into the wild and corrupt wild populations' genetic pools.  Alaskan fishermen, for example, warn that their wild stocks are being infiltrated by Atlantic salmon bred in fish farms.

"The potential for Atlantic salmon to compete with our natural wild salmon or to spread diseases is an ongoing concern and part of the reason the United Fishermen of Alaska opposes finfish farming," said that group's executive director, Mark Vinsel.

The efficiency of fish farming is another question.  Fish farmers have been known to feed eight pounds of fish for every pound of fish they raise, said Andy Rosenberg, a U.S. Ocean Commission member and former deputy director of the National Marine Fisheries Service.  Fish farming, he said, "has the potential to produce high-quality seafood, but you need to do it carefully and it needs to be managed in a comprehensive way."

MORE FROM SCIENCE

Science Section Front

Did ancient Sicilians build temples to ‘fit in’? Shipping alert issued over giant iceberg Discovery reveals where dinosaurs originated Real Christmas trees ‘greener’ than fake Big bang machine sets smashing new record In some bird species, females are pretty too Baby alligator, snakes found in university dorm Big flood may have created Mediterranean Sea Petunias and potatoes may be carnivorous iPhone app lets you bird-watch on the go Science Section Front   Add Science headlines to your news reader: