New radio formats
sacrifice sound quality

The headline on the March issue of Wired proclaims “The End of Radio (As We Know It).” Inside are stories on the satellite radio wars, the coming digital radio boom plus radio recording devices and even podcasting. I disagree with the whole premise. Radio isn't ending -- all that's happening is we're getting more of it. And while the options may be better, sound quality is being sacrificed.

Let me explain. As I think we can all agree, commercial broadcast radio in the United States, for the most part, sucks. AM radio has been relegated to talk and FM stations play music — of sorts. Stations are Xerox copies of similar stations, playing the same songs over and over again.

Satellite radio partially solves this by giving you a huge choice of stations: Songs from every decade, genre, style and persuasion are available on both XM and Sirius services. Your choices are amazing, but what about the audio quality?

Satellite radio sound is, at best, barely passable. That’s because your satellite service provider sends only one digital signal to your receiver. The receiver then splits that signal into hundreds of audio streams: some, for voice, very narrow; others, for music, a little wider. I’ve been told these streams run from a few kbps for voice to something like 30 to 60kbps for music.

A typical music satellite radio station is thus compressed and expanded at a much lower rate than many MP3s. A reader will write me to defend the sound of a 128kpbs ripped music file (it’s not near-CD quality despite what anyone tells you) but I can’t believe anyone can defend the sound quality of a 36kbps satellite radio music stream.

Compare that to the way a good FM station can and does sound.  It’s not even close.  It’s like the difference between hearing a symphony in a recital hall versus listening outdoors on a transistor radio. These days, a low-end satellite receiver will set you back $100. For the same price you can get a Tivoli table radio which sounds 1,000 percent better than any music stream from either of the two satellite companies.

There are probably at least one or two FM stations in your area which transmit a great signal and music you want to hear. They’re worth seeking out. Public radio, college and classical stations sound best here in New York City. 

MORE FROM TECH AND GADGETS

Tech and gadgets Section Front

Twitter phishing ploy goes for ‘Direct Messages’   Apple doesn’t seem to like mixing apps, politics LinkedIn and Twitter link up   Apple can see Microsoft on the horizon Online holiday shopping is trickier this year What your Facebook photo says about you Auction site launches for millionaires only Tagged.com settles with states in invite fight Sony offers ‘Cloudy’ for buyers of Internet TVs French president's Facebook photo disputed Tech and gadgets Section Front   Add Tech and gadgets headlines to your news reader: