NASA revisits tale of three tragedies

NASA marks its saddest days of the year over the coming week, beginning with Thursday's 38th anniversary of the Apollo 1 fire, which killed three astronauts and set back America's rush to the moon by 21 months.

The week of triple tragedy continues with the 19th anniversary of the Challenger explosion on Friday and next Tuesday's second anniversary of the Columbia's disintegration. Each of those disasters killed seven astronauts and grounded the rest of the shuttle fleet for more than two years. NASA's human spaceflight program still hasn't fully recovered from Columbia's loss, but the agency is on track to resume shuttle flights in May.

To mark the occasions, NASA Administrator Sean O'Keefe will lead a "Day of Remembrance" ceremony at the space agency's headquarters at 2 p.m. ET Thursday, to be aired on NASA Television. Additional observances will be conducted at six other NASA centers Thursday, and Kennedy Space Center in Florida has scheduled a Columbia memorial service at 9:30 a.m. ET Tuesday at its visitor complex.

Catastrophes and challenges
At last year's remembrances, the crew members of Columbia and Challenger were memorialized at Arlington National Cemetery and even on Mars — and O'Keefe exhorted NASA employees to remember "every single day that the consequences of us not getting it right are catastrophic." That message is likely to be underlined this year.

During the current gap in shuttle flights, investigators have delved into the causes of the Columbia tragedy, just as their predecessors did for Apollo 1 and Challenger. After each of the three tragedies, causes were found and changes were made:

• Apollo 1: The fire that broke out during a launch-pad test on Jan. 27, 1967, was caused by an electrical short circuit and fed by a high-oxygen atmosphere within the crew cabin. The three astronauts — Gus Grissom, Roger Chaffee and Ed White — were trapped inside the cabin due to a poorly designed escape hatch. As a result of the investigation, more than 1,000 changes were made in the command module's design.
• Challenger: On the exceptionally cold morning of Jan. 28, 1986, gaps in the seals on Challenger's solid rocket boosters provided an opening for hot rocket exhaust to flare out and ignite the shuttle's liquid fuel tank, sparking a fiery explosion that blew the orbiter apart. All seven crew members — Dick Scobee, Michael Smith, Ellison Onizuka, Judith Resnik, Ron McNair, Greg Jarvis and space teacher Christa McAuliffe — died in the fiery fall on Jan. 28, 1986. Shuttle components were redesigned and launch procedures were changed.
• Columbia: Investigators say a piece of flying foam from the shuttle's fuel tank knocked a hole in the leading edge of Columbia's left wing during the shuttle's ascent, allowing hot gases to enter and destroy the shuttle from within during its re-entry 16 days later, on Feb. 1, 2003. The seven crew members — Rick Husband, William McCool, Michael Anderson, David Brown, Kalpana Chawla, Laurel Clark and Israel’s Ilan Ramon — were all killed. The shuttle fuel tank has been redesigned, and new procedures provide more opportunities for inspection and backup, although there is still no proven method for fixing a Columbia-scale gap in the shuttle's skin.

In all three cases, NASA's management approach came in for as much criticism as the specific causes of each accident. During the Apollo days, the tendency to launch without resolving all the safety questions was called "go fever." After Challenger and Columbia, NASA was taken to task yet again for an overly lax attitude toward safety, made tragically clear in retrospect.

INTERACTIVE NASA's glory days Space timeline of the 1960s and 1970s

This time around, NASA says that it's addressing what the Columbia Accident Investigation Board called a "broken safety culture," and if top managers can't adjust, they'll have to go.

For all the parallels linking NASA's three tragedies, the aftermath of the Columbia's loss is subtly different: Apollo 1 caught fire at the very beginning of the Apollo program, and Challenger blew up toward the start of the shuttle program. After Challenger, the shuttle Endeavour was built to bring the shuttle fleet back to its full strength of four.

In contrast, NASA is not planning to build a replacement for Columbia. Rather, the Columbia tragedy brought home the message that the fleet's days were numbered.

MORE FROM SPACE

Space Section Front

The year in space   2009's best images from space How much real science is in ‘Avatar’? Mystery swirls around ‘dark stars’ Cassini image confirms liquid on Saturn moon Long-defunct Mars rover wheel spins Crew blasts off for Christmas space mission Earth's upper atmosphere cooling dramatically Cosmic Log: Koreans plan space tours Mars probe's latest trouble: Titanium parts   Space Section Front   Add Space headlines to your news reader: