Ape fossil bridges evolutionary gap

By Diedtra Henderson

updated 7:12 p.m. ET Nov. 19, 2004

The last probable common ancestor to humans and great apes had a body like an ape, fingers like a chimp and the upright posture of humans, according to researchers who unearthed a fossil of the animal in Spain.

A husband-and-wife team of fossil sleuths reopened an excavation site near Barcelona, discovering a 13 million-year-old animal that bridges the gap between earlier, primitive animals and later, modern creatures.

This newest ape species, Pierolapithecus catalaunicus, is so significant that it adds a new page to ancient human history.

The researchers sidestepped a controversy raging through the field by not claiming their find moves great ape evolution — and the emergence of humans — from Africa to Europe. Salvador Moya-Sola said the new ape species likely lived in both places.

“The problem is the fossil record,” Moya-Sola said. “The fossil record in Africa, especially in the upper Miocene, is very scarce. And the fossils are very rare. But this is only a question of work, and work, and work.”

'Missing link'?
Coaxed by a reporter to say Pierolapithecus catalaunicus represented a “missing link,” co-author Meike Kohler demurred. “I don’t like, very much, to use this word because it is a very old concept.”

Kohler added: “This does not mean that just this individual — or even this species, exactly this species — must have been the species that gave rise to everything else which came later in the great ape tree. But it is, if not the species, most probably a very closely related species that gave rise to it.”

Maybe. Maybe not, argues David Strait, an assistant professor anthropology at University at Albany who studies early humans. He said the team’s approach to assigning evolutionary relationships was a bit informal and needs confirmation by more rigorous methods.

“‘Ancestor’ is a loaded term. It’s very hard to identify ancestors in the fossil record,” Strait cautioned.

'A remarkable find'
The site that yielded the Spanish specimen had only one hominid, or ape-like primate. Moya-Sola said fossil apes, however, were common in the area millions of years ago. The team has already found a tooth elsewhere and expects to find more hominid fossils.

Still, scientists who puzzle through the mysteries of early human history were electrified by the Pierolapithecus catalaunicus discovery, published in Friday’s issue of Science magazine.

Science Complete bones and bone fragments from the Spanish specimen are arranged in this composite photograph.

“This is a remarkable find,” said F. Clark Howell, a University of California at Berkeley professor emeritus. “It indicates a diversity in hominids ... in western Eurasia at a time where we’re beginning to think we had a good handle on how much diversity there was.”

Howell helps run a National Science Foundation initiative that examines hominid origins.

Living great apes include humans, chimps, gorillas and orangutans. The group is thought to have split from the lesser apes, such as gibbons and siamangs, about 14 million to 16 million years ago.

Paleontologists have searched for remains of great ape ancestors after that key split. Fossils have been scarce, and hypotheses have been floated on the basis of bone fragments.

The team led by Moya-Sola and Kohler pieced together 83 bones and identifiable fragments of bones from an adult male ape.

But this ape didn’t swing through trees with the curved fingers of an orangutan. Nor did it knuckle walk on four limbs with the horizontal trunk posture of a chimp.

“It’s a different type of animal,” Moya-Sola said.

Meike Köhler An artist's conception shows what the face of the newly discovered specimen, dubbed Pierolapithecus catalaunicus, might have looked like 13 million years ago.

The ape’s body design suggests it was an adept and agile climber that kept its trunk upright. To do that, its chest had to be shaped just so. And the shoulder blades needed to hold to a certain position on the back.

“Our fossil shows this,” he said.

What it does not show is the evolution of hands suited to the demands of such locomotion as swinging through tree branches. That fine-tuning of great ape hands, the team argues, came later.

MORE FROM SCIENCE

Science Section Front

Decades of future science Santa Claus: The real man behind the myth First Jesus-era house found in Nazareth How much real science is in ‘Avatar’? Turkey-sized dino packed venom in its fangs Chimps master first step in controlling fire The decade's highs and lows in science Even bacteria get lonely The shortest day: The science of the solstice Biggest atom smasher begins year-end break Science Section Front   Add Science headlines to your news reader: