Kerry: Bush plan
on Social Security
is a ‘rip-off’

updated 7:34 p.m. ET Sept. 22, 2004

ORLANDO, Fla. - Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry on Wednesday called President Bush’s proposal to partially privatize Social Security “a rip-off” that would create a windfall for financial and investment companies but end up cutting benefits for senior citizens.

“The truth is, the only people who benefit from George Bush’s Social Security scheme are the special interests,” Kerry said in remarks prepared for a town-hall meeting in West Palm Beach, Fla., a battleground state rich in people keenly interested in the two pillars of retirement, Social Security and Medicare.

Kerry’s two-day swing through Florida, which began Tuesday, follows deadly hurricanes that nearly halted polling and politicking in the state. Bush made his third campaign-season trip to Florida this week to assess damage caused by Hurricane Ivan. Kerry has been to the state that decided the 2000 election nine times this year.

Bush favors allowing young workers to create voluntary personal savings accounts with some of the money they now pay into the Social Security system, a change he insists will not increase payroll taxes or change benefits for retirees or near retirees.

Kerry, however, contended that diverting money from Social Security to private accounts was a “bad, old idea.”

“That’s not a plan, it’s a rip-off,” he said. “George Bush’s scheme hurts seniors by cutting benefits, and it hurts our economy by increasing the deficit.”

Kerry pointed to a study by Austan Goolsbee, a University of Chicago business professor, who studied a model that proposes workers set aside a small percentage of their pay in private accounts as a method to adjust Social Security to a rapidly graying population.

Goolsbee concluded that fees charged by financial companies could reap them hundreds of billions of dollars and eat 20 percent of the benefits in an account held by a worker making an average salary.

The Bush-Cheney campaign said Kerry hasn’t explained how he’d meet the challenges posed to Social Security by aging Baby Boomers.

Kerry record questioned
“His record is one of voting for higher taxes on current retirees and ignoring the needs of future retirees,” said Bush campaign spokesman Steve Schmidt.

Voting problems, how voting systems work, contacting state election officials

Kerry wants to bolster the retirement program by reducing the deficit and expanding the economy. Some experts say economic growth might be insufficient to cover future benefits because those benefits grow as wages increase.

The Massachusetts senator also wants to improve Medicare by retooling the recently passed prescription drug benefit to let the government negotiate for bulk discounts on drugs.

FREE VIDEO Campaign warfare on Iraq Sept. 22: President Bush and Sen. John Kerry traded attacks on Iraq policy and national security. NBC's Kelly O'Donnell reports. Nightly News

Kerry talked to voters in Orlando and Jacksonville in Florida on Tuesday, promoting his health care plan and criticizing the president’s conduct in Iraq.

Bush’s record in Iraq means he “does not have the credibility to lead the world,” Kerry told reporters. He also questioned Bush’s rebuff of a CIA intelligence survey. Bush said “they were just guessing as to what the conditions might be like.”

“Does that make you feel safer? Does that give you confidence that this president know what he’s talking about?” he asked supporters at a late-night rally in Orlando.

MORE FROM POLITICS

Politics Section Front

House Dems to tax rich for health care Obama lands in Ghana after meeting pope NYT: Ghana visit points to Africa's instability Sept. may bring push for Iran sanctions Post-9/11 surveillance went beyond wiretapping Newsweek: How Obama looked past the Kremlin Obama's visit to fort a 'full-circle experience' Mock exercises prepare Sotomayor for hearings Obama plane incident could have been disaster Lawmaker: Panetta terminated secret program Politics Section Front   Add Politics headlines to your news reader: