Skip navigation

As the political convention season opens, Hardball launches a blog in its own rough-and-tumble image that no pol can afford to ignore

Hardblogger.MSNBC.COM

July 28, 2004 | 4:19 p.m. ET

One if by land, two if by sea (David Shuster) John Kerry chose the sea Wednesday. His Boston arrival was another highly choreographed and yet picturesque moment.

The Kerry campaign has the imagery nailed. There was Kerry with his Vietnam crew mates, standing on the deck of a boat sailing through Boston harbor and docking at the  Charlestown Navy Yard. I was half-expecting Jim Rassman to jump overboard so Kerry could re-enact his famous Vietnam rescue. We've seen and heard so much this week about Kerry's "band of brothers" that I'm beginning to wonder if anybody else actually served in Vietnam?

This afternoon, I got a lift back to the MSNBC workspace from a Massachussetts state senator. (Note to convention goers: there are no taxicabs at Charlestown Navy Yard.) Anyway, the state senator told me that the navy yard (closed in 1973 and refurbished in the last few years) stands as a lasting symbol of the political "payback" that Richard Nixon liked to inflict. In the 1972 presidential election, Massachussetts was the only state to go with McGovern over Nixon. So, the Nixon administration retaliated by closing down the navy yard. Thousands of Massachussetts jobs were lost.

By the way, check out our report at 7:30 p.m. ET on VP nominees. It looks at the drama and chaos the running-mate selection process used to bring to the Democratic convention. It's our best work of the week.

The man behind Hardball's curtain (Dominic Bellone Hardball Producer & Briefing Editor)

So I was heading to the dock at the Boston Harbor waterfront behind my hotel this morning when I see a bunch of secret service types and a big boat. I figured someone important, maybe the Governor of New Jersey, was arriving. Turns out Kerry was on his way from the airport to take the water taxi over to Charlestown Navy Yard for his big "splash" arrival in Beantown. It was pretty cool to see Kerry kickin' it at the location where I was jogging this morning and catching the water taxi. Shuster was over covering his landing for the network.

Tonight's a big night as they do the traditional roll call of states announcing their number of delegates plus Edwards' big speech. My colleague Brian Doherty checks in from the Democratic "Tong" with this disturbing piece of news:

"This will not be a typical VP convention speech. There will be no mention of Bush or Cheney. It's Edwards view that we can get into the issues that are important to the American people without personal attack. He won't get into personal invective."

How boring.

By the way, The Tong is the nickname for the private briefing the Kerry camp gives to each television network during the day to push its daily message and goals for the night.

Going through our rundown tonight it appears we have another wingding of a show lined up...And folks our booking producers have been killing themselves for weeks to get these guests. You'd think booking people would be like shooting fish in a barrel but its not. Chris' big theme for the night is "Us vs. Them" politics, a play off of Edwards "Two Americas" campaign theme. Watch for him to ask questions in that vein.

Our 6-8 ET All-Star Panel is Ron Reagan, Dee Dee Myers (who owes me a blog posting), Chuck Todd of The Hotline & Pat Buchanan from Washington.

The 9-Midnight panel is Willie, Andrea, Howard and Scarborough. Some of our All Star guests: Rep. Charlie Rangel, D-N.Y., Howard Dean, the dynamic duo of Russert & Brokaw, (Al Sharpton speech), Ralph Reed, Steve Buscemi (aka Tony "B" from The Sopranos) and Director Rob Reiner (Dig the Drudge piece today).

Frank Luntz wraps up the 11 o'clock hour with one of his famous focus groups from Ohio. We'll do the cool dial speech thing where the focus group members turn the dials up and down in real time as they watch the speech with instant reax. As always, this is just an aperitif for you and we'll have much more news, guests and surprises from Faneuil Hall.

And, yo, dig this hot piece of press published in The Boston Globe today.

July 28, 2004 | 2:58 p.m. ET

From the Hardblogger mail box:

Re: Anticipating Kerry

From: Holli, Alexandria, Va.
I wonder what Kerry's speech will be like. I really hope that he has a plan. I think that boils what the country is looking for down to one thing, a real actual plan for fighting terrorism that makes sense yet still holds to our American ideals. People want real leadership and I hope that's what Kerry shows on Thursday night. I know he's got it in him.

Re: Frank's post

From:  Gordon Toggweiler, Lawrence, NJ
Both on the show yesterday and in his post today, Frank Luntz made the point that Tuesday was a far less effective day for the Dems than Monday because it was too partisan and wouldn't play well with swing voters. He missed the point however.Tuesday was the day for the liberal base not for the swing voters, because it was the day not being carried by the broadcast networks. Unfortunately for the Dems, the made the mistake of not putting Obama in broadcast prime-time.

Re: On What is "Middle America?"

From: Lauren Fischer, Chicago
I'm glad to see folks from Peoria and Kansas telling Joe Scarborough that he was incorrect when he said that Teresa Heinz Kerry would not strike a chord with people in "Middle America." I don't think it matters where you live -- if you're a woman, you have to love what THK has to say!!! Teresa Heinz Kerry rocks.

Re: Chris

From: Christine Flood, Casselberry Florida
"I am big fan of Chris Matthews but I do not understand his romantic ideas of small town life and people out in the hinderlands such as myself. We do not usually ask people who they would like to have a beer with as a means of selecting our candidate or eat at Busy Bee Diner and talk to our fellow diners over the mashed potatoes and meatloaf asking their opinion of Teresa Kerry speech. We go to the Outback wait for our table and talk to our spouses. I do not think these romanitized rural and small town folk are much different. Maybe Mr. Matthews should join us on a Saturday night at the Outback for a drink and some conversation and see the real America."

Re: Joe

From:Ellen Silver, Van Nuys, California
Joe, over the past several weeks from the selection of John Edwards as Kerry's running mate -- you have demonstrated non-partisan critiques that are heartfelt and professional. Last night when you spoke of your child's Type I Diabetes you went beyond partisan rhetoric and spoke of the hope that stem cell research would provide. As a Nation we all benefit by hearing and listening to opposing sides of an issue. Its called debate. You bring honest dialogue and are not 'nasty' or disrespectful of others with opposing views. MSNBC is smart to have you as their 'other' point of view.

And, in a more circular vein, some e-mails reacting to e-mails:

In "Re: the blog by Vinnie Chieco of San Francisco:"

Vinnie, Teresa Heinz Kerry was not adamant that she hadn't used the term "un-American." That is as inaccurate and revisionist a recounting of the event as it occurred as the original offense to Ms. Kerry was. As it was stated, Ms. Kerry referred to "un-American traits" in her speech, not "un-American activities" as she was accused. -Beth Christensen, Chatsworth

Vinnie from SF hit it right on the head about THK's "shove it" incident! But leave it to the biased, liberal press to gloss over the fact that she's on tape saying "un-American" for all to hear! She's doing the flip-flop as well as her husband.- S. Belano, Coconut Creek, FL

July 28, 2004 | 12:40 p.m. ET


Obama envy? (Conservative magazine editor
Terry Jeffrey)

Barack Obama’s speech was sensational, introducing him as a new star in American political life. But with slight tinkering, Obama could have delivered the same speech at the Republican convention next month to just as rousing a response.

The speech was notable largely for the inspiring story of Obama’s family background, which he told with eloquence and passion, and not for any particular cause or issue that Obama wants to champion. 

His call for national unity was indeed stirring: “There’s not a liberal America and a conservative America. There’s the United States of America.” But in the day-to-day politics Obama will encounter in the Senate next year (where he is almost certain to be elected), he will have to take unambiguous stands on profound issues that do deeply divide Americans. 

Would he stand with Teddy Kennedy and the Democratic leadership, for example, in blocking by filibuster the appellate court nomination of California Supreme Court Justice Janice Brown, an African-American raised in rural Alabama, under segregation, whose personal story is as inspiring as Obama’s own? Stay tuned.

July 28, 2004 | 10:45 a.m. ET

Monday's vs. Tuesday's speeches (Pollster Frank Luntz) It is quite interesting how different the mood and language of the Democrats are outside the Hall than from the podium.  Monday was one of the most effectively scripted convention days I have ever seen.  Very positive.  Very optimistic.  Very uplifting.  Even notable divisive politicians like Hillary Clinton and Al Gore had effective words that would appeal to the swing voters.  I have attended every convention since 1984 and I have only once before seen an eruption in support as positive as was given Hillary when she arrived on stage—  and she did not disappoint the throng.  

Tuesday wasn't as effective, mostly because of Ted Kennedy's very partisan rhetoric. 

To reach the swing voters, Edwards and Kerry will need to return to Monday's language that transcends partisanship and ideology.  While it may not turn on the most hardcore Democrats, it will certainly play better at home.  

July 28, 2004 | 10:00 a.m. ET

From the Hardblogger mail bag...  in case you missed the coverage last night:

On Barack Obama's speech:

All I have to say is that in 8 years or so, we may have our first African-American President in Barack Obama.  I’m from Illinois and I will be very proud to have both he and Dick Durbin in the Senate.  His message is perfect! He is, as Andrea Mitchell said, a “rock star” who will fight not only for Chicago, not only for rural Illinois, but for the whole country. -Anonymous

A third of the way into Barack Obama’s speech I turned to my wife and said,”There is the first black President of the United States.”  He gave a very comprehensive, visionary, and moving speech.  The future looks very bright if he is an example of the young politicians who will replace the aging “yes men” we currently suffer. -John Vandenburg, Indio, CA

On Ron Reagan's speech:

Really great speech, Ron!!  It alone should have turned millions of normal and average Americans in a nonpartisan manner to look at the real issue of "life saving" research with the promise to treat millions of lives,... worldwide.  I'm just overwhelmed at your gift to communicate this message before the DNC. I think your father is looking over you on this cause! ... :) -Dom Manalo, Baltimore

Ron Reagan has been an embarassment to his father as he never held his views. After making political comments at his father's funeral, which were totally inappropriate, he lost credibility. He would not be in the spotlight now if he wasn't capitalizing on his name.-Rose Cohen, Massapequa Park, NY

On Joe's comment that Teresa Heinz Kerry won't play well in "Peoria":

Hey, I'm from Peoria.  You were asking how Teresa Heinz came across here.  She hit a homerun.  I found the video that the democrats provided [before she spoke] to be an eye opener into her past.  She seems like she will be able to connect with people all over the world.  So does she play in Peoria?  You bet. -Jeff Nau, Peoria, IL

Regarding the "Shove it" comment by T.H.K., I don't hear anyone talking about what I think is the most important part of the exchange. She was wrong. She was adamant that she hadn't used the word "un-American" and she had. Not only that, the comment was not delivered, excusably, in the heat of the moment. After an initial confrontation, she pushed through her body guards to be offensive. Mrs. H.K. needs to understand (billionaire status aside) that before you exhibit righteous indignation, you need be right. And before you can be First Lady, it helps to be a lady. -Vinnie Chieco, San Francisco

Hey Joe Scarborough, I can't imagine that you think you are qualified to critique Teresa Heinz Kerry from the viewpoint of women in "Peoria". I live in a small town in Kansas, and I admire Teresa for speaking her mind, having brains and using them. She's great! A wonderful role model for our young women. - Diane Jones, Pleasanton, Kansas


(Click here to read more Hardblogger e-mails.)


Sponsored links

Resource guide