Skip navigation

Miley voted worst celebrity influence of ’09

Tweens and teens on youth site put her ahead of Britney and Kanye

Image: Singer Miley Cyrus
The poor showing of the singer-actress Miley Cyrus in poll of the worst celebrity influence of 2009 follows a year that has seen Cyrus controversially dating a 20-year-old model, making "slant eyes" in an informal snapshot criticized as mocking Asians, and being accused of pole-dancing on a teen awards show.
Chip East / REUTERS
  Celebrity video
Paula Deen hit by a flying ham
  Nov. 24: Celebrity chef Paula Deen is recovering this morning after she was hit in the face by a ham being unloaded at a charity event in Atlanta. TODAY’s Ann Curry reports.

Slideshow
Image: Elizabeth Hurley
  Best and worst celebrity fashions of 2009
From glamorous gowns to stylish suits to complete fashion failures, a look at the year so far.

more photos

updated 1:55 p.m. ET Oct. 28, 2009

LOS ANGELES - Miley Cyrus, one of Disney's hottest stars of the past three years with hit records and hit films, has been voted the worst celebrity influence of 2009 by the very people who made her a star, tweens and teens, according to an online poll on Wednesday.

Cyrus, 16, took 42 percent of votes in the poll for AOL's JSYK.com (Just So You Know) Web site aimed at 9-15 year-olds, pushing Britney Spears and rapper Kanye West into second and third places, respectively, in a section on worst celebrity influences of the year.

No reasons were given for the poor showing of the singer-actress and the popular star of Disney Channel's "Hannah Montana" television series.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

But the ranking follows a year which has seen Cyrus controversially dating a 20-year-old model, making "slant eyes" in an informal snapshot criticized as mocking Asians, and being accused of pole-dancing on a teen awards show.

Cyrus also came in No. 4 in the category of favorite female artist, behind 19-year-old country sensation Taylor Swift, "I Kissed a Girl" singer Katy Perry and R&B star Beyonce. The poll attracted almost 50,000 votes.

Slideshow
Image: Zac Efron
  Hollywood's youth movement
Zac Efron, Hilary Duff and Dakota Fanning are among the new generation of actors and singers who are lighting up screens, radio stations — and tabloid headlines.

more photos

"I think Miley is in an interesting space where she is trying to graduate from being 'Hannah Montana' and a Disney channel celebrity and coming into her own and having a career beyond Disney," said Stephanie Cohen, editor of JSYK.com.

"I think her fans still want her to be the sweet Hannah Montana and she is trying to age up. ... Parents are definitely resisting it," Cohen told Reuters.

Cyrus has been one of the biggest teen idols in the world since 2006, selling more than 7 million albums, starting her own fashion line, and taking $154 million at the worldwide box-office for "Hannah Montana: The Movie" in 2009.

West, whose interruption of Swift's acceptance speech at a music award show in September was deemed the most shocking moment of 2009, took 19 percent of votes in the worst celebrity influence section.

Swift, the best-selling U.S. artist of 2008, has risen again in popularity this year.

"I think Taylor Swift has done a great job of showing her true self and coming across as very sweet and down to earth. A lot of her songs are about the underdog and teens can really relate to her," said Cohen.

Elsewhere, the stars of vampire movies "Twilight" and its forthcoming sequel "New Moon" dominated the JSYK.com poll. Kristen Stewart was voted favorite female movie actress and Taylor Lautner surged past Robert Pattinson in both the favorite male movie star and "cool guy you'd like to hang out with" categories.

Copyright 2009 Reuters. Click for restrictions.

Sponsored links

Resource guide