Plenty of drama, little dancing on ‘SYTYCD’

By Kate Ward

updated 6:47 p.m. ET Oct. 22, 2009

Hold on a minute. I did spend an hour last night watching "So You Think You Can Dance," right? So how come I feel like I sat through an episode of "Extreme Makeover: Home Edition"? There were cheers, hugs, and enough tears to put M'Lynn Eatenton herself to shame. But where was the dancing?

Of course, I understand that choosing each season's top 20 is a dramatic affair. And it is admittedly enjoyable to watch the judges give the dancers good news through cruel speeches like: ''You're a wonderful dancer...but we need to see you grow...and we think you will...but somewhere outside of the competition...as well as in the competition...Did I remember to pick up my dry cleaning?...That's right, I did...and I stopped at Wal-Mart on the way home and got a great deal on light bulbs...which shine almost as bright as you...and that's why you're in our top 20.''

But in previous seasons, we were allowed at least a glimpse at the top 20 dancers' solos. Last night? We only saw a few seconds of Billy Bell's solid solo, a routine that we'd already been given a chance to experience last week. Come on, SYTYCD! You could have cut all that footage of Mollee and Noelle playing MASH and Pretty Pretty Princess to make room for just a few solos, right?

So the lack of dancing in last night's episode left me unsatisfied. But the news the judges dropped on us in the show's final minutes left me utterly heartbroken. Just as I was firming up my prediction list — which we will get to shortly — the judges informed us that Paula Von Oppen declined their top 20 offer because she was already contractually bound to a film.

And to that I say: Hell to the no! My favorite female dancer of the season bows out of the competition? Please: Somebody deliver Tyce Diorio to my apartment right now so I can punch something! (Because you know you wanted to after hearing him smarmily reject a contestant by telling her, ''Please continue on your shining journey,'' a sentence that was less genuine than a pair of studs from Claire's). Watching Ashleigh replace Paula in the top 20 was a bit like watching blue M&Ms replace tan M&Ms: I understand that it was a necessary move, but I'd prefer the reliable to the flashy. Alls I got to say is that better be one heckuva of a movie, Paula. And good luck to ya!

Now, on to the dancers who survived the walk of truth to nab a spot in season 6's top 20. (The "Close Encounters" stage lighting was sure appropriate, considering Mia's new Ellen Ripley cut, eh?) Though it's tough for me to weigh in much about our dancers — thanks to the lack of, you know, actual dancing — take a look at my predictions for the season! (Keep in mind that I'm taking into account the fact that we lose both a girl and a guy each week. And keep in mind that these are my predictions, not a countdown of my personal favorites.) In descending order...

Slideshow   Celebrity sightings Jennifer Garner and a host of stars celebrate “Valentine’s Day,” Charlie Sheen makes an appearance in court, Sandra Bullock scores a Super souvenir and more. more photos

20. Ariana Debose: Can you say cannon fodder? Considering the contemporary dancer has been more difficult to spot than a polar bear in the snow — I honestly can't remember if we had ever seen her before last night — I'd say her chances of making it past week one are pretty slim. But who knows? Maybe this Derose will prove me Dewrong and Debloom next week.

19. Victor Smalley: I was on Victor's side in Atlanta. (Those pirouettes!) But Victor would have to magically transform into the Kool-Aid guy to break through this season's solid group of contemporary dancers. Especially since the judges forced him to shave off his Mohawk. (Perhaps they feared he'd accidentally get pulled onto the "Top Chef" set?) But that hair certainly worked for last season's Küpono and season 4's Mark. So, take my advice, Victor: Grow the hair back! Then, perhaps nostalgic fans will pick up the phone.

18. Karen Hauer: Karen is certainly easier to swallow than fellow ballroom dancer Ashleigh. But a severe lack of camera time over the past few weeks could hurt her chances to go far. Plus, when trying to think of something — anything — to write about Karen, I come up completely empty. And that's saying a lot, coming from the girl who could write a treatise about belly button lint.

17. Phillip Attmore: I love me my tappers. And I loved me my Phillip back in Los Angeles, when we first met the guy. But last night, we saw a glimpse of the dancer's slightly arrogant and defensive attitude in Vegas. (Funny that this is the first we've seen of it, right?) My guess is SYTYCD fans will be turned off by any semblance of an attitude. And this is real attitude — not Danny Tidwell ''attitude.'' Phillip could very well redeem himself with some seriously awesome moves, but he has to keep in mind that this is the search for America's favorite dancer, not America's insecure-to-the-point-of-douchbaggery dancer.

16. Ellenore Scott: Like Ariana, we have barely seen anything from Ellenore. But I'm rolling the dice here and placing her ahead of Karen nonetheless. And who knows? She could be the next Sabra or Jeanine, two winners who received barely any screen time prior to the top 20 performances. Plus, I'm on her side, if only because the name Ellenore reminds me of The McLaughlin Group. (''Eleanor gee-I-think-you're-swell-anore!'')

15. Legacy: Unlike some of the contestants above, Legacy has scored plenty of camera time. But will he be this season's Ivan, or this season's Jonathan? Based on what we've seen, Legacy has the passion, but not the technique. And without Mia on board to back him up for the rest of the season, I'm not sure if the b-boy will be able to impress judges, as well as viewers who already find him phony.

14. Kathryn McCormick: Hey, "Price Is Right" fans: Do you remember the game ''Cliff Hanger''? The one where the contestant must make the yodeler ascend the mountain without falling off? Do you remember that tense feeling you get watching the yodeler climb the mountain? You kind of rise up in your seat watching him go higher, and higher, and higher...That's the feeling I get listening to Kathryn speak. Oh my god, was that annoying or what? Yet, at the same time, hilarious. That's why I'm hoping Kathryn sticks around long enough to officially transform into Stewie Griffin.

13. Peter Sabasino: Like others, Peter could suffer from lack of camera time. But I sure hope he doesn't. He's cute, Italian, and a tapper. What more could you want?

MORE FROM TELEVISION

Television Section Front

Jay Leno ends NBC prime-time experiment TV’s 50 biggest bombs and blunders ‘Lost’ star Daniel Day Kim cast in ‘Hawaii 5-0’ Super Bowl is most-watched program ever Leno wore disguise to Super Bowl spot taping Fox, Conan need to set rules if he joins network ‘Modern Family’ a freshman hit for ABC Howard Stern confirms ‘American Idol’ talks Tebow Super Bowl ad strikes light-hearted tone NYT: What do Spike TV, Lifetime tell us about sexes? Television Section Front   Add Television headlines to your news reader: