Fact or fiction? Government as 'honest broker'

Claim: President Obama believes the government should be 'an honest broker' between patients and doctors.

Much of the debate over the Democrats’ insurance proposals has focused on how active a role the government should have in deciding what treatments patients get, especially if they’re in the Medicaid or Medicare programs where their care is paid for mostly by taxpayers. Should government funds pay for almost every procedure patients and doctors think they need — or should the government steer patients away from certain costly treatments?

Fact or fiction?
Fact. Obama said last May doctors always know more than their patients about particular treatments, implying that this potentially put patients at a disadvantage. "What I think government can do effectively is to be an honest broker in assessing and evaluating treatment options," he said. "And certainly that's true when it comes to Medicare and Medicaid, where the taxpayers are footing the bill and we have an obligation to get those costs under control." He said for example, the government might tell a patient in a particular case "the blue pill, which costs half as much as the red pill, is just as effective."

Send us a health care claim you'd like msnbc.com to investigate — and check back for your daily dose of reality. E-mail us at , submit your question on Newsvine or tweet @msnbc_health using the tag #doseofreality.

MORE FROM DOSE OF REALITY

Dose of Reality Section Front

Fact or fiction? Reform means income tax hike Fact or fiction? States may exit Medicaid Fact or fiction? Stimulus could help pay the bills Fact or fiction? Reform hurts retiree benefits Fact or fiction? Buy-in only a partial solution Fact or fiction? Expand Medicare, risk solvency Fact or fiction? A Senate short cut to enactment Fact or fiction? Medicare is already rationing Fact or fiction? Bill won't cut Medicare benefits Fact or fiction? GOP added to Medicare's costs Dose of Reality Section Front   Add Dose of Reality headlines to your news reader: