Positive parenting: Get past teen stereotypes

When it comes to adolescents, too many parents are quick to focus on what they do wrong. That's a big mistake, says author Richard M. Lerner in his new book, “The Good Teen.” An excerpt.

It is a mistake to embrace the stereotype
Think about it: when was the last time you heard a parent praise his or her teenager? When was the last time you did? Most likely you’re like Nancy. Whenever she met a friend in the library who asked how Donna was doing, Nancy would immediately say, “Forgetful and inconsiderate, as always.” If she was asked to describe Eric, the first things she thought of were what a slob he could be and how he often lost track of time — as if these constituted his entire personality rather than just two aspects of it. Only during rare moments, such as during her conversation with Rob, was she able to stop dwelling on her children’s faults and see their strengths.

Sometimes I am convinced that many parents do not even have a useful vocabulary to describe teens who aren’t “troubled.” Although we’re comfortable acknowledging academic achievement (usually in the form of school grades), when it comes to other aspects of their lives, we mostly describe “good” kids as either those who have learned to manage or cope with their shortcomings or ones who don’t have problems. That is, we resort to negatives: good kids don’t do drugs, don’t hang out with the wrong crowd, and don’t engage in risky behavior.

To many parents, the absence of bad things is the definition of a good kid. They think, “My child is doing well because she’s not in trouble.” Do we even have enough words to depict all the important, valuable, admirable, and positive things that a young person can do?

Have we forgotten how to affirm their positive characteristics? This collective amnesia is more serious than you may at first realize. Our lack of vocabulary isn’t innocuous — it’s a symptom of a much larger public and scientific problem that has serious implications, both for individual teenagers and for our society at large. By focusing our conversations with friends on risks and dangers, and by our fascination with reading the incessant media accounts that emphasize the negatives of the teen years, we’ve implicitly accepted a theory of adolescence that’s based on deficits. When we view teenagers as deficient — as if something’s wrong with or missing from them — it affects them. Acknowledging our low expectations, hearing nothing but their shortcomings, they feel vulnerable. Ultimately, they may come to believe that it is inevitable that they will become involved in problematic or dangerous behavior. They may incorporate the sense of actually being “at risk” as living only a step away from getting in trouble or creating problems for others, whether it involves taking drugs, dropping out of school, becoming pregnant, or getting caught up in violent behavior.

Imagine if everywhere you turned people thought poorly of you — if every time you read an article or saw a TV news report about people your age, you realized that no one expected very much of you. Surrounded by these impressions, it wouldn’t take long for you to feel burdened by the incessant accusations and suspicions. Some teens become convinced that their parents are just waiting to discover incriminating evidence or are always on the verge of asking invasive and accusatory questions: “Are you smoking cigarettes? Are you smoking dope? Are you having sex?”

Video   Teenage girls under pressure Feb. 10: TODAY’s Meredith Vieira talks to psychologist Dr. Stephen Hinshaw and 20-year-old college student Liz Funk about ways to help teen girls battle intense social pressures. Today show

What a dispiriting, disheartening outlook! Teens who grow up in this atmosphere can have their self-esteem deflated, their motivation and spirit dampened. After all, when people don’t expect the best of us, we often respond in kind.

Sheila, for example, wanted her fourteen-year-old son, Andy, to help out with household chores. Since he loved their cat, Star, Sheila asked her son to be responsible for cleaning out the kitty litter box twice a week. At first, he was fairly responsible. But after a couple of weeks, Sheila found herself having to remind him. Within a month, she was nagging him all the time.

One day Andy was in the kitchen and overheard his mother on the phone talking to a friend, complaining about what a pain it was to constantly remind Andy to do his chores. “I’m sorry that I ever asked him to do this,” he heard his mother say. “We always end up yelling at each other. But what I’m really worried about is that he doesn’t know how to be responsible. He has to learn that life’s not all play, that sometimes we have to do chores that we don’t enjoy.”

Andy waited until later that evening to say to his mom, “I heard you on the phone, and you have it all wrong. It’s not that I don’t want to help out around the house — it’s just that I hate doing the kitty litter. I can’t stand the smell.”

Sheila was speechless. She’d known since he was a baby that Andy was very sensitive to smells. Of course it made sense that being in charge of changing the litter was not the best chore for him. After talking with him and asking about his preferences, they decided together that Andy would do the laundry. And because he had no natural aversion to this job, Sheila almost never had to remind him to do it.

But what also struck Sheila most painfully was how quickly she’d assumed that Andy had just been defiant and oppositional ... because that’s how teenagers are supposed to act. They’re supposed to rebel, to resist doing chores, or doing anything their parents ask of them. They look for any opportunity to turn a discussion into an argument, and leave their parents no choice but to nag. Because Sheila accepted everything she’d heard about teenagers at face value, she never thought to wonder if there was another reason for Andy’s behavior beyond “being a teenager.”

MORE FROM WORKING MOM'S GUIDE

Working Mom's Guide Section Front

The good, the bad and the funny of parenting Moms want to share chores (but not power) Hot mama! Pregnant women can still have style Maternal sin: Moms confess their secrets ‘Sneaky’ recipes to feed kids veggies Mom confession: My sanity depends on nanny Trying to conceive? Nancy O’Dell has advice Tori Spelling: A nose job for her baby? Moms: Can you really work from home? Waiting for baby (on Facebook) Working Mom's Guide Section Front   Add Working Mom's Guide headlines to your news reader: