Amber Alert systems vary greatly by state

updated 10:43 a.m. ET Nov. 20, 2008

ATLANTA - Authorities count hundreds of Amber Alert cases across the country as success stories when they start explaining why the media-friendly and politically popular bulletins are so important.

Yet despite a federal law meant to create a uniform system, an Associated Press review shows wide variations in what triggers an Amber Alert from one state to the next, which can heighten the tension when a suspect crosses state lines.

The AP examined Amber Alert records from all 50 states and found that some barely keep track of the alerts they've issued, let alone whether they worked. A few states don't have anyone designated to oversee their programs.

That poor record-keeping makes it difficult to tell whether investigators have ever missed a chance to safely recover an abducted child because of differences in the state laws and their application.

Twelve states refuse to put out an alert when a parent calls police amid a custody fight, while others see that as a legitimate reason to enlist help from the public. Twelve states issue Amber Alerts for adults with mental or physical disabilities, while other states save their bulletins solely for abducted children.

Among the disparities those different interpretations create: New Jersey has issued just four alerts since 2005, while Michigan — with an only slightly larger population — has issued 100.

All that despite a 5-year-old federal law requiring that every state have a child abduction alert system in place. The law also requires that those systems be uniform to help coordination and that the U.S. Department of Justice appoint someone to get the states on the same page.

Do alerts help find children?
Critics question the basic premise of Amber Alerts — that they help find and save abducted children. Kidnappers who kill children usually do so in the first six hours after they take their victims, experts say. Often it takes nearly that long just to get an alert issued.

A few days after she disappeared in April 2006, 10-year-old Jamie Rose Bolin of Purcell, Okla., was found dead in a neighbor's apartment, the victim of what investigators said was a cannibalistic fantasy. Police did not initially put out an Amber Alert because they suspected she had run away and had no reports of an abduction.

An alert was eventually issued, but police said the girl probably was killed the day she was taken.

"There's nothing wrong with making people feel better in the security of children — it does exactly that," said Jack Levin, a criminology professor at Northeastern University in Boston. "When you're actually talking about preventing homicides, you have to look elsewhere for a solution."

Law enforcement officials insist the alerts can be crucial to recovering endangered children, even when multiple states are involved.

Take the case of Jerry Jones, who killed his infant daughter and his ex-girlfriend's parents and sister in a small north Georgia town before kidnapping the couple's other three kids. Motorists saw an alert on a highway sign and spotted the Ford Explorer driven by Jones, who was caught just across the Tennessee line and given a death sentence earlier this year.

The three children were found safe, and the Levi's Call, as Amber Alerts are known in Georgia, "was the key to the whole thing," said John Bankhead, a spokesman for the Georgia Bureau of Investigation.

Amber Alerts started in 1996 after the murder of 9-year-old Amber Hagerman, who was kidnapped while riding her bicycle in Arlington, Texas. The city developed a system where police work with broadcasters to put out bulletins on abducted children, similar to severe weather warnings.

Soon, states began creating their own Amber Alert systems, and Congress established its own law in 2003.

The federal law doesn't have any teeth to it, though. It sets basic standards for issuing an alert but doesn't penalize states that don't follow them.

MORE FROM CRIME & COURTS

Crime & courts Section Front

Rural S.C. terrorized by 5 killings in past week   Ex-D.C. Mayor Barry charged with stalking Bust nets heroin stuffed in toys Cops: Ariz. mom led sons on crime spree Cop nabs robber minutes after graduating Ruling disappoints MySpace victim’s mom Drug raids reveal 'sobering' mass of arms Cops hunt serial killer after 4 shootings Crime & courts Section Front   Add Crime & courts headlines to your news reader: