Great Depression colors seniors’ view of crisis

updated 5:18 p.m. ET Oct. 15, 2008

MILTON, Fla. - Marcelle Uptain grew up during the Great Depression, so her response to the recent bank turmoil, the stock market plunge and home foreclosures was simple — take her money out of the bank and hide the cash at home.

Her son had to talk her out of it.

"I have a little steel box with a key and I was thinking about taking my checking account out and putting it in there," said Uptain, 83, who grew up in Alabama and lives at a senior center here.

For Americans who lived through the Depression, the last few months have felt like deja vu. Many of them are pulling money out of the bank, shopping for discounts and warning younger relatives about darker days that may lie ahead.

George Eckhoff, 95, worries the latest crisis could be even worse than the one of his youth because of rising food prices. He gets meals from his assisted-living apartment in Seattle, but remembers the bread lines and bank lines.

"Your food and everything is so high," he said. "I don't know how people will make it this time."

While there are no hard figures available, banking officials say more seniors are asking to withdraw their savings. Sales of safes are up as much as 50 percent in the past three weeks at SentrySafe, the nation's top safe manufacturer.

At the start of the Depression, the federal government did not guarantee bank deposits, so many people in their 80s and 90s recall withdrawing money — or arriving too late and seeing their savings disappear.

That's unlikely to happen today because the federal government insures most individual bank accounts to $250,000. But for seniors like Uptain, that assurance can be a hard sell.

"If you've lived through the Great Depression, you believe it can happen again," said Robert Binstock, a Case Western Reserve University professor of aging, health and society. "This all evokes the era of bank failures in the Depression, and they think burying money in a glass jar is a safer bet."

The collapse of some banks and the forced sale of others helped set today's financial crisis in motion — although it's a far cry from the thousands of bank closures during the Depression.

Bernanke: Too soon to tell if recovery will last Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke says it is still too early to declare that the budding recovery will last. Obama to lay out plan to combat joblessness theGrio: Black teens' unemployment rate spikes NYT: U.S. forecasts smaller loss from bank bailout Unexpected drop in jobless rate fuels optimism

During the three months that ended June 30, the latest period for which data are available, domestic bank deposits fell by nearly $40 billion, according to the Federal Reserve. They now stand at around $7 trillion.

When IndyMac Bank failed in July, hundreds of angry customers lined up for hours in Southern California to demand their money. And a rush of withdrawals from Washington Mutual Inc. last month put it in an "unsafe and unsound condition to transact business," according to federal regulators, who ultimately seized the bank and sold it to JPMorgan Chase & Co.

Banker Kathy Phillips has spent much of the last two weeks encouraging customers, especially older customers, not to withdraw large amounts of cash.

"The last thing you want people to do is walk around with $10,000 in cash in their pocket," said Phillips, a vice president at Pensacola-based Gulf Coast Community Bank. "We explain the risks of taking it out in cash, try to divert them to cashier's checks, offer to wire it someplace else."

MORE FROM ECONOMY AT A CROSSROADS

Economy at a Crossroads Section Front

Bernanke: Too soon to tell if recovery will last Obama to lay out plan to combat joblessness theGrio: Black teens' unemployment rate spikes NYT: U.S. forecasts smaller loss from bank bailout Unexpected drop in jobless rate fuels optimism Obama sees some consensus at job summit New jobless claims drop unexpectedly Bleak job scene poses challenge for Obama AIG slashes amount it owes U.S. by $25 billion Blacks fear path to middle class blocked Economy at a Crossroads Section Front   Add Economy at a Crossroads headlines to your news reader: