Chinese Muslims at Gitmo: U.S. not enemy

updated 8:52 p.m. ET Oct. 9, 2008

SAN JUAN, Puerto Rico - A Chinese Muslim locked up at Guantanamo Bay may soon be granted an improbable wish: to move to the United States.

A federal judge this week ordered the man and 16 other members of an ethnic group from western China freed from Guantanamo and brought to his courtroom, but an appeals court late Wednesday gave the Bush administration at least a week to come up with arguments against the move.

Statements over the years by the Uighurs held at Guantanamo since 2002, reviewed by The Associated Press, indicate they consider America an ally but are angry they have been imprisoned for so long.

Guantanamo has been steeped in controversy since suspected al-Qaida and Taliban members were first sent to the base in Cuba in chains in January 2002. Human rights groups and lawyers said people who had nothing to do with either group were swept up in the aftermath of 9/11, some sold to U.S. forces in Pakistan and Afghanistan for bounties. The Bush administration insisted only the "worst of the worst" were taken to Guantanamo.

But even the U.S. government now says the Uighurs, from an ethnic group that allegedly suffers repression from the Chinese government, are not enemy combatants.

The Bush administration is unwilling to send them home because they face abuses in China, so it is trying to find other countries to take them. It says they're too dangerous to "let loose" on U.S. streets because they allegedly received weapons training.

Grouped with terrorists
In their statements to military panels at Guantanamo, the Uighurs said they left China to escape repression or look for work because Uighurs were denied good jobs at home. They said that if they felt hostility toward any country, it was China and not the United States.

They have been held at Guantanamo alongside suspected al-Qaida and Taliban members.

"I want you to explain why I have been grouped in with those terrorist people," said Arkin Mahmud — the detainee who dreams of moving to the U.S. — told a Guantanamo panel almost three years ago. The Army colonel presiding over the Administrative Review Board said his panel didn't need to explain why Mahmud was in Guantanamo.

Mahmud denied receiving weapons training and laughed when a soldier suggested he had plans to attack the United States. "No, of course not," he responded.

He did, however, acknowledge that he had lashed out at Guantanamo prison guards.

"When a regular person is just doing his business and ... then ends up in prison, that is frustrating and sometimes you get mad," he said.

"I would like for the United States to take me and I will stay there the rest of my life in peace," Mahmud said, when asked what country he would like to go to.

Rebiya Kadeer, president of the Uighur American Association, said Uighur families in the Washington area are willing to house the men. Brant Copeland, a pastor from Tallahassee, Fla., said in a conference call with Kadeer and journalists that his community is ready to welcome them — even though he hasn't found anyone there who speaks their Turkic language.

Years in detention
Mahmud told his Guantanamo tribunal that he was a shoe repairman and had gone to Afghanistan in search of his brother, who is also among Guantanamo's 17 Uighurs. Uighurs are from China's impoverished Xinjiang region bordering Afghanistan, Pakistan and six other nations.

The brother, in a separate tribunal, acknowledged that he had learned how to use a Kalashnikov in Afghanistan. He told the panel that he sought independence for his region, which Uighurs sometimes call "East Turkistan."

"We need a country like the U.S., like a powerful country, to help us," said Bahtiyar Mahnut, whose surname is spelled slightly differently from his brother's in military documents.

In 2002 — after the Uighurs were detained — the United States declared the East Turkistan Islamic Party a terrorist organization amid intense lobbying from China. Several of the Guantanamo Uighurs are accused of associating with the group.

Mahnut said China wants to make the Uighurs look bad and urged his military panel to "really look carefully" into the issue. He also dismissed al-Qaida members as lunatics.

"They just destroy everything, and we're not crazy like those people," he said.

MORE FROM TERRORISM

Terrorism Section Front

NYT: Cheney linked to hiding of CIA project Italian freed in Philippines after 6 months NYT: Fears rise over al-Qaida branch U.K. police probe Gitmo detainee’s claims Pakistani scientist: ‘Not against America’ Terrorism Section Front   Add Terrorism headlines to your news reader: