O.J. Simpson's future now hangs on appeal

updated 5:49 p.m. ET Oct. 7, 2008

LAS VEGAS - O.J. Simpson's attorneys in his armed robbery case could be fighting long odds to convince an appeals court that he was a victim of racial prejudice and payback for his murder acquittal, legal experts say, but there may be other grounds for a new trial.

The 61-year-old Simpson's future depends, in part, on how successfully his lawyers argue that his 1995 acquittal was allowed to intrude in a Las Vegas courtroom.

Las Vegas defense attorney Al Lasso said that while the former football star's acquittal was the "elephant in the room everyone was trying to ignore," there were other errors that could bring a reversal of his conviction.

"This court would not hesitate to reverse if they saw cumulative errors that had the effect of prejudicing a defendant," Lasso said. "But then again it's O.J. Simpson, and he's unlike any other defendant."

Lasso, who watched the trial, said he was shocked at the jury's decision to convict Simpson and co-defendant Clarence "C.J." Stewart of kidnapping, armed robbery and 10 other charges related to a hotel confrontation Sept. 13, 2007, with two sports memorabilia dealers.

The two face up to life in prison.

The day after the verdict, Simpson lawyer Yale Galanter said the jury was "on an agenda" to make up for Simpson's acquittal.

"This was just payback," Galanter said.

Lasso agreed, saying the conviction "feels like revenge justice."

The defense also will claim Judge Jackie Glass put such tough limits on defense questions that lying witnesses were shielded from exposure in court.

But the race issue will be the most difficult to prove, according to Sam Sommers, a Tufts University psychology professor whose area of expertise is race and the justice system.

"Short of attorneys admitting that, it's hard to convince an appeals court that it happened," Sommers said.

Both men are black and their jury included no African-Americans. Two blacks were eliminated by the prosecution through peremptory challenges in spite of defense claims that these were race-based actions designed to create an all-white jury.

One of the nine women and three men who convicted Simpson identified herself as Hispanic.

Is O.J. asking for new trial?
Simpson remains isolated in a 7-foot-by-14-foot cell in a Las Vegas jail, and his attorneys said they were preparing a request for new trial to be filed by week's end.

Attorney Gabriel Grasso said that request, which is expected to be denied, will offer a preview of appellate points to be raised after Simpson's scheduled sentencing Dec. 5.

Kidnapping is punishable by five years to life in prison. Armed robbery carries a mandatory sentence of at least two years behind bars, and could bring as much as 30 years.

"In the motion for new trial, you're asking the person who tried the case to admit they screwed up," Grasso said. "It's very rare those are granted."

Nevertheless, Dayvid Figler, a Las Vegas criminal defense lawyer, said the request for a new trial can be a prelude to sentencing and could include evidence of good deeds and character references, "basically to paint a picture of O.J. Simpson other than what we were left with."

"I would jam it full of stuff, get affidavits from the two victims saying they weren't really in fear and weren't victims," Figler said.

Once Simpson is sentenced, Grasso said, the focus will be on an appeal to the Nevada Supreme Court, which is the only appellate court in the state. An appeal could take a year and a half to resolve, and Simpson and Stewart would probably remain behind bars during that time.

Of all the potential appeal issues, Galanter said, "the worst was jury selection."

Galanter said the defense will argue that the judge's efforts to speed up jury selection "limited our ability to fully explore juror bias."

MORE FROM CRIME & COURTS

Crime & courts Section Front

NYT: Fort Hood suspect tracked before shooting   AP: Man admits killing abortion doctor Supreme Court won't stop sniper execution   Source: Hasan reached out to imam   Recession’s good news: Burglaries fall High court looks at life in prison for juveniles Inquiry in Ohio bodies case widens worldwide 3 Fla. teens charged as adults in fire attack Kansas town still grieves ‘In Cold Blood’ deaths   More than 20 dead animals found at home Crime & courts Section Front   Add Crime & courts headlines to your news reader: