Skip navigation

Reality TV ’08: If it ain’t broke ...

Networks leaning on old favorites, including ‘Survivor,’ ‘Home Makeover’

IMAGE: Ty Pennington
Ty Pennington returns on "Extreme Makeover: Home Edition."
Vivian Zink / ABC
ComediesDramaRealityReturning
  Television video
  Sesame Street turning 40
Nov. 8: Sesame Street marks its 40th anniversary on Tuesday on PBS. Msnbc's Alex Witt talks with In Touch Weekly's Tom O'Neil about the landmark TV show for children.

COMMENTARY
By Andy Dehnart
msnbc.com contributor
updated 3:34 p.m. ET Sept. 17, 2008

Once again, the major broadcast network are sticking to a fairly predictable pattern with their fall reality TV offerings, mostly airing new seasons of their popular series.

All of the major network reality series have aired over five seasons, and most are well over 10, with one, "Survivor," rapidly approaching its 20th season.

There are a few new shows, but very few are catching early buzz.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Here's a look at what's coming up this fall on the networks' big six reality TV shows, followed by highlights from both broadcast and cable.

"The Biggest Loser 6: Families"
Premieres: Sept. 26, 8 p.m., NBC

What's new? The weight-loss competition will undoubtedly continue to offer incredible transformations in its overweight contestants, who will continue to vote each other out. This season, besides making every episode two hours long, producers and NBC have again cast only pairs of contestants with pre-existing relationships; as the title suggests, they're pairs of family members this season.

Worth watching? The diet-and-exercise-only weight loss is always inspiring, but fast-forward through the product placement and the filler during the unnecessarily long weigh-in ceremony.

"Survivor: Gabon"
Premieres: Sept. 18, 8 p.m., CBS

What's new: The basics stay the same — tribes compete against one another in challenges while braving the elements and each other, with the losing tribe voting off one of their own at Tribal Council — but there will be one significant change. For the first time, the groundbreaking reality competition will be shot in high definition.

INTERACTIVE
Image: Survivor Gabon
Meet the ‘Survivor: Gabon’ cast
A look at the 18 contestants that will vie for the $1 million prize this season
And they've certainly picked a visually stunning location for that. "Survivor" will return to Africa, filming in Gabon, a relatively uninhabited country on the western coast of the continent that the show has labeled "Earth's Last Eden." Unlike the barren lands of Kenya, Gabon offers a combination of rainforest-like areas and savanna that's covered with amazing natural amphitheaters that will host challenges and Tribal Council.

The 18 cast members, who I interviewed before the game started, range from an Olympian (Crystal) to an actress (Sugar), a doctor (Marcus) to a high school teacher (Bob). They seemed to belong to one of two groups: people who were there just for fun or to challenge themselves, and those who are cutthroat competitors, and they're also pretty evenly divided between likable people and those with obnoxious personalities. How all of that materializes once the game starts is, of course, yet to be seen.

Worth watching: Absolutely. Even after 16 seasons, "Survivor" continues to deliver unpredictable drama and engaging characters.

However, the show is coming off one of its most compelling seasons ever, "Survivor Micronesia: Fans vs. Favorites," which had a record number of blindsides and brilliant strategic moves. In other words, the cast of "Gabon" has a lot to live up to. But if they do not, seeing those cast members, never mind the always-stunning landscapes and animals in high definition, will probably offer enough distraction so we won't notice for a while.

"America's Next Top Model 11"
Premieres: Sept. 3, 8 p.m., The CW

What's new? As gossip magazines have already revealed, Isis, one of the 14 competitors, is transgendered. Tyra Banks loves to refer to her wannabe models as her "girls," so for the first time this season, one of those girls will be biologically male. Otherwise, it's modeling as usual.

Worth watching? Maybe. Tyra seems to be focused more on her talk show than her reality show, and "Top Model" has aged rapidly the last few seasons, although some viewers thought it rebounded in season 10.

"Dancing with the Stars 7"
Premieres:
Sept. 22, Mondays at 8 p.m. and Tuesdays at 9 p.m., ABC

Slide show
Image: SUSAN LUCCI, TONY DOVOLANI
  'Dancing With the Stars'
A look at the new cast, including actress Susan Lucci.

more photos

What's new:
Only the cast. As always, B-, C-, and D-list "stars," some of whom you've never heard of (Jeff Ross?), will be paired with professional dancers and asked to learn and then perform dances in front of a panel of highly opinionated judges.

While the cast includes its share of reality show has-beens — "Rock Star INXS" host Brooke Burke, "Restaurant" star Rocco DiSprito, and socialite Kim Kardashian — there are some actual talented people you may have heard of on the show this season, including Olympians Misty May-Treanor and Maurice Greene, singer Lance Bass, and actors Cloris Leachman, Susan Lucci, and Ted McGinley.  Also cast: Toni Braxton, Cody Linley, insult comic Ross, and Warren Sapp.

Perhaps more interestingly, there will be new dance pros, including Mark Ballas' father Corky, who will dance with Leachman, and "So You Think You Can Dance 3" finalist Lacey Schwimmer, who will be paired with 'N Sync's Bass. Both have wide fan bases and lots of talent in the dancing department (although Lacey much more than Bass), so look for them to dominate.

Worth watching? The show always manages to be entertaining thanks to the rehearsal footage, the actual dances (whether they're impressive or disastrous), and the judging.

"Extreme Makeover: Home Edition"
Premieres: Sept. 28 at 7 p.m., 8 p.m., ABC

What's new? After spending two seasons traveling to all 50 states for extreme home renovations, Ty Pennington and company will continue their mission to enlist communities to help build spectacular new homes packed with Sears-sponsored appliances for deserving families.

Worth watching? If you need a good cry, some feel-good TV, or renovation ideas, absolutely.


  MORE FROM FALL TV PREVIEW  
  
Fall dramas try to offer something for everyone
 
Add Fall TV Preview headlines to your news reader:
 

Sponsored links

Resource guide