Skip navigation

The Obama racial subtext surfaces in Iowa

Edwards parries a voter's question about Obama and the O.J. verdict

IMAGE: John Edwards, Barack Obama
Presidential hopefuls former Sen. John Edwards, D-N.C., and Sen. Barack Obama, D-Ill., await the start of last Thursday's Des Moines Register Presidential Debate in Iowa.
Scott Olson / Getty Images
NBC Video: Politics
Ensign scandal snowballs
July 9: Sen. John Ensign, R-NV, admitted today that his parents gave his mistress, Cindy Hampton, and her family $96,000, before the affair became public. Was Ensign trying use campaign funds for hush money? Rachel Maddow is joined by Las Vegas Sun columnist John Ralston, who interviewed Cindy Hampton’s husband Doug.

Slideshow
  The Week in Political Cartoons
Msnbc.com’s political cartoonists take a look back at the past week.

more photos

By Tom Curry
National affairs writer
msnbc.com
updated 7:37 a.m. ET Dec. 17, 2007

Tom Curry
National affairs writer

E-mail
ELKADER, Iowa - As Democratic presidential contender John Edwards fielded questions from a crowd of about 100 people in Elkader, Iowa (population 1,374) Friday night, he got one of those out-of-left-field queries for which a candidate needs his sharpest wits.

An elderly man told Edwards that “something has been sticking in my craw” and explained that “a certain fella committed two murders in California and the jury found him not guilty. And all they said was, ‘It’s payback time.’ How are you going to have that come out in this election to combat one of your competitors?”

Edwards seemed puzzled, as most people in the audience seemed to be.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

“The black jury in Los Angeles, the reason they found O.J. not guilty was ‘payback,’” the older gent explained.

“Payback for what?” Edwards asked.

For mistreatment by white America, the man said.

“What do you want the president to do about that?” Edwards asked.

“How are you going to get that brought out in your campaign? Will the same thing happen? If he should become elected, you think Al Sharpton, Jesse Jackson, Oprah Winfrey are going to let him forget about that and their obligation?” the man said, not identifying who he meant by “he” and “him.”

“I’m still not sure what it is that you’re asking,” Edwards said, a bit uneasily.

Voter questions O.J. verdict
“Obama,” the man said, “has never said anything about payback for the problems the blacks have had getting their foothold in society.”

NBC News video
Making his case
Oct. 7: John Edwards speaks to Tim Russert about why he believes he's a stronger presidential candidate than his rivals Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton.

Meet the Press

It wasn’t exactly clear, but the man seemed to want Barack Obama to denounce the “not guilty” verdict in Simpson’s 1995 trial.

Where a presidential contender stood on O.J. had apparently become this voter’s litmus test. There was also the implication in his question that if you vote for Obama, you get Sharpton and Jackson in the bargain.

Edwards said to the man that he’d work to “create the kind of opportunities for African-Americans that all Americans are entitled to.”

Edwards noted that African-Americans have higher rates of poverty and are more likely to not have health insurance than whites. He added, “Instead of focusing on what happened with O.J., what I want to do is focus on what I see as the underlying causes of those things, poverty in America, lack of health care, lack of opportunity….”

This may have been just one old eccentric in a small town, but there is a racial subtext lingering in the minds of some voters in Iowa.

A way to overcome racism
Some Obama fans say they plan to support him in the Jan. 3 precinct caucuses partly to prove that America has overcome racism and that the White House is open to someone who is, as Obama describes himself, “a black guy born in Hawaii with a father from Kenya and a mother from Kansas.”

A few hours before Edwards handled that O.J. question in Elkader, he had a campaign event at a Manchester, Iowa, steakhouse.

Rita Domeyer, a retired farm wife from Dyersville, showed up to listen to him.

“I like Obama; I read his book and I think he had quite an upbringing, and he handled it very well,” Domeyer said, as she waited for Edwards to arrive on his campaign bus. “I’m not racist and I don’t like to hear anybody say, ‘Because he’s black he can’t win.’”

  Picking the president: The candidates
Click to visit that candidate's MSNBC page or click the XML symbol for an RSS feed.


John McCain               

Barack Obama

She added that she does believe that Obama can win and that his Kenya-Kansas parentage would not be a liability in an election. “But you hear a lot the other way; we’re pretty white around here, you know,” she said.

Iowa is indeed “pretty white.” According to exit poll interviews in 2004, only 1 percent of the state’s electorate was black. The Census Bureau reports that non-Hispanic whites make up 92 percent of Iowa’s population, while non-Hispanic whites make up 67 percent of the total American population.


Sponsored links

Resource guide