Skip navigation
sponsored by 

Giuliani assails Huckabee's tax plan

He says the 'fair tax' proposal could hurt home buyers

Chuck Burton / AP
Republican presidential hopeful and former New york Mayor Rudy Giuliani speaks during a "North Carolina Women for Rudy" event at North Carolina A&T University in Greensboro, N.C., Monday, Dec. 3, 2007.
Video: Decision '08  
  
House conducts non-impeachment impeachment hearing
July 25: Though it was technically a House Judiciary Committee hearing on “Executive Power and its Constitutional Limitations” the theme of the day was violations by the Bush Administration that amount to impeachable offenses. Libertarian Party presidential candidate Bob Barr, who testified at the hearing, talks with Countdown’s Keith Olbermann.

INTERACTIVE
Candidate Brain Trusts
See who is in the inner circles of the campaigns of Republican John McCain and Democrat Barack Obama.

NBC News

Slide show
Image: Barack Obama.
Barack Obama
The Democratic presidential candidate in photos, from childhood to party leader.

more photos

Slide show
US Senator John McCain (R-AZ) smiles as he is inte
A legacy of service
Sen. John McCain’s life has revolved around the public need.

more photos

updated 4:04 p.m. ET Dec. 3, 2007

GREENSBORO, N.C. - Republican presidential hopeful Rudy Giuliani criticized the "fair tax" proposal of rival candidate Mike Huckabee on Monday, saying it could hurt home buyers.

The former New York City mayor cited the struggling U.S. housing market as a reason to avoid the plan, which would eliminate all taxes on income and investments in favor of a hefty federal sales tax.

"I think there are several tax deductions that are vital to our economy," Giuliani said. "This would not be a good time — I don't know if there would ever be a good time to do this — to advocate ending the home mortgage deduction. The home mortgage deduction is considered by many critical to the ability of people to buy a home and keep their home."

Story continues below ↓
advertisement

He also said deductions for charitable contributions and state and local taxes were important tax breaks that Huckabee's plan would eliminate. The plan calls for getting rid of the Internal Revenue Service and giving taxpayers a monthly rebate on taxes on purchases up to the poverty line.

"Why waste our time trying to do this if we can't actually accomplish it?" Giuliani said. "I try to put my time into things that we can actually accomplish."

Still, Giuliani said he, too, wants to simplify the tax code so a return could be completed with one piece of paper.

Image: Huckabee
Yana Paskova / Getty Images
Republican U.S. Presidential hopeful Gov. Mike Huckabee on November 30, 2007 in Des Moines, Iowa.

Huckabee is running about even in Iowa with Mitt Romney, according to a Sunday poll in The Des Moines Register. Huckabee is at 29 percent to Romney's 24 percent with a 4.4 percentage point margin of error. Giuliani is at 13 percent.

Giuliani spent much of his time in Greensboro criticizing Democratic proposals on health care, education and pensions. He said the Democratic presidential candidates touting those programs are pushing the country toward more taxes when it needs more investment in private business.

On education, he discussed his plan for school vouchers, saying a lack of choice in education "may be the biggest civil rights issue" of the day. Giuliani said he — not the Democrats — was best suited to handle the millions of Americans who live in poverty.

"We have to have a society that rewards success," Giuliani said. "The only way in which we get people out of poverty is you help them help themselves by giving them the opportunity for a good education and the opportunity for a good job. That's how you deal with poverty — not with government welfare programs."

  Picking the president: The candidates
Click to visit that candidate's MSNBC page or click the XML symbol for an RSS feed.


John McCain               

Barack Obama

Copyright 2007 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Sponsored links

Resource guide

Get Your 2008 Credit Score

Search Jobs

Find your next car

Find Your Dream Home

Find a business to start

$7 trades, no fee IRAs