UAW’s ‘victory’ may really be last gasp

While the United Auto Workers tentative deal with General Motors may look like a victory for labor, it really shows that a once-powerful union is gasping for life.

The power center of U.S. unions is no longer the industrial sector, with once dominant forces like the UAW at the forefront. Today, the big union guns are in service industries less susceptible to outsourcing — everything from health care to hospitality.

“For a long time, the UAW was the face of the labor movement but it’s not where the power is in organized labor any more,” says Julius Getman, labor law professor at the University of Texas School of Law, and author of “Strike.”

Indeed, the UAW ranks 12th among U.S. unions with about 538,448 members. The  National Education Association is the largest with 2,767,696 members, and the Service Employees International Union is second with 1,575,485 members, according to BNA, a specialized news and information publisher.

The unions leading the charge to organize service sector and public employees — including the SEIU, Unite Here, the Teamsters, the United Food and Commercial Workers International union and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees — are the new face of labor in the United States today, Getman explains.

“Labor has become much more dynamic than it was 20 years ago,” he adds, because the focus is on organizing a whole new group of workers.

It has a long way to go.

Membership among the labor movement as a whole has been declining for decades, thanks to globalization, tighter legal controls on union organizing and a growing discontent with unions. In 1977, nearly 24 percent of workers were union members. Last year, that number hit 12 percent.

Many labor experts believe the big industrial unions rested on their laurels, unwilling to see the impending doom that was decimating their ranks. “The UAW and the Steelworkers unions tried to hold on to past gains and tried to figure out globalization,” says Gary Chaison, professor of Industry relations at Clark University, Graduate School of Management.

But in recent years, a call to intensify organizing among service sector jobs has helped reinvigorate some unions that were willing to branch out beyond their industrial roots.

More on the UAW and GM Local UAW leaders give GM deal the go-ahead GM could save $3B a year after new auto deal UAW’s ‘victory’ may really be last gasp UAW reaches tentative agreement with GM Newsweek: Back on the road Who should pay for health benefits?   Discuss: Autoworkers' benefits too much?

The new voices of the labor movement, he explains, “are talking about organizing Wal-Mart and reinventing the Civil Rights movement, bringing power in the workplace to workers who are on the margin of society.”

“If I said to (UAW president) Ron Gettelfinger, ‘you should go organize Wal-Mart,’ he’d look at me like I was crazy,” he adds. “The UAW used to be one of the most innovative, militant unions, now it finds itself moving backwards.”

The effort to shift the focus reached a crescendo in 2005, when a group including the SEIU and the Teamsters, decided to break off from the old guard stalwart AFl-CIO, a federation of many different unions. The leaders that led the split, most vocal of them among them the SEIU’s Andy Stern, said they were sick of continued decline in membership and wanted to intensify organizing efforts.

But many also saw it as a rift between the old and the new economies. On the one side were the jobs that were easily exportable outside the country, says Jim Ferber, a labor law attorney with Littler Mendelson. And on the other side, he adds, “were the jobs in those industries that were not only growing in the U.S. but jobs that can’t be outsourced.”

MORE FROM AUTOS

Autos Section Front

NYT: Plan to sell G.M.’s assets approved ‘Car guys’ retrain but downshift to lower pay The cars that will likely set the pace in 2014 Smart in court, Chrysler struggles in showroom Cup holders paved way for interior car design Auto sales declines show signs of steadying Official: No funding for GM after July 10 GPS for autos starting to get ‘smarter’ Newsweek: Why 'cash for clunkers' is flawed Chrysler Financial to cut 9 percent of workers Autos Section Front   Add Autos headlines to your news reader: