Skip navigation

‘Tired eyes’ watching our skies

Stressed, antiquated air-traffic control system in need of overhaul

Image: Air-traffic controller
Michael Dwyer / AP file
Matt McCluskey directs air and runway traffic from the control tower at Logan International Airport in Boston.
Video
Audio: Two planes nearly collide on runway
Aug. 2: Listen to the Air Traffic Control tapes as two planes nearly collided at Philadelphia International Airport last weekend. WCAU's Tim Lake reports.

NBC News Channel

  Top slideshows
Koya-san World Heritage Site
EPA
  World Heritage Sites
From amazing to mysterious, view the natural, cultural, archaeological and architectural wonders of the world.
Image: Waimea Canyon, Kauai
Lonely Planet Images
  Polynesian paradise
The Hawaiian Islands are the perfect vacation destination for travelers of all types.
Image: The Pitons seen from Anse Chastanet
  Caribbean way of life
From chic to rustic, expensive to affordable, tourists looking for some sun and sand can find what they're looking for in the Caribbean.
OPINION
By Charles Leocha
Travel columnist
Tripso
updated 12:32 p.m. ET Aug. 3, 2007

Charles Leocha
Travel columnist

E-mail
Thousands of Americans are waiting on the tarmac for hours. Hard-earned vacations are squandered. Businesses are losing hundreds of millions of dollars on lost time and extra travel expenses.

All I can say is "No wonder!" The U.S. air traffic control (ATC) system is literally creaking at its seams. And yet this antiquated system is now serving more flights and aircraft than at any time in the history of aviation. All signs are pointing to an impending meltdown that will dramatically impact air travel in the United States. It's time for Congress to wake up and deal with the many problems faced by the nation's ATC system.

  • Air travel across the country is at an all-time high; in fact, it has surpassed pre-9/11 air traffic.
  • The ATC technology behind the system hasn't been updated in decades.
  • Many air traffic facilities are understaffed.
  • Experienced air traffic controllers are retiring at a higher rate than anticipated.
  • Junior air traffic controllers are handling traffic at our busiest airports before having a chance to hone their skills at smaller facilities as they did in the past.
Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Combined with these problems, the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has allowed the airlines to pack more and more planes into busy airports and their congested airspace that simply cannot meet the published take-off and landing schedules, even on a good day, with full ATC staffing.

And then there's the technology issue. Experts have been discussing the technical limitations of the current ATC system for years. Unbelievably, our air traffic controllers are using decades-old technology. However, a partisan Congress and the hapless FAA have not figured out a way to move modernization forward. The discussion of this is far too complicated for a few paragraphs.

Trouble on the ATC side
Even more pernicious, is the impending staffing crunch of the highly trained air traffic controllers who operate our control towers and watch radar screens. According to the Dallas Morning News, U.S. Special Counsel Scott J. Bloch who has studied ATC problems revealed by whistleblowers at the FAA, pointed out that the number of controllers at Dallas/ Fort Worth has dropped to 68 from 100 about five years ago. "I'm not saying that leads to more errors, but it means you've got tired eyes watching the skies," he said. "They're having to work more airplanes, more days, more hours."

  Christopher Elliott on security

Bogus bomb threats, other events
expose troubled security system

Air Transport World reported that according to National Air Traffic Controllers (NATCA), one of the factors ignored in the final U.S. National Transportation Safety Board's (NTSB) investigation of the 2006 crash of a Comair flight at Lexington, Ky., was that a single controller was on duty at the time of the accident and had turned away from the window to handle paperwork when the CRJ taxied onto the wrong runway.

The larger problem of retiring controllers and their sinking morale is looming on the not-too-distant horizon for the FAA and the American traveling public. A Government Executive analysis published this July paints an ugly picture of unhappy controllers. This general disgruntlement combined with the fact that these controllers were hired en bloc in the early 1980s adds an ominous wrinkle to the situation.

It appears Marion Blakey, the FAA Administrator, felt the air traffic controller pay scale had increased unreasonably and when negotiations between the NATCA and the FAA were declared at an impasse last year, Blakey imposed a pay increase that averaged less than two percent a year over five years. This heavy-handed "settlement" did not rest well with the NATCA.

To add insult to injury, according to Government Executive, "In addition to slowing the rate of raises, the terms FAA required cut starting salaries from between $38,080 and $53,312 to $31,700 and eliminated incentive pay for controllers who move to more challenging facilities or take on supervisory duties. The agency also instituted new rules to restore managerial control, including a dress code and restrictions on entering and leaving air traffic control facilities."


Resource guide