Brazil jet in crash was speeding down runway

updated 5:41 p.m. ET July 19, 2007

SÃO PAULO, Brazil - Officials struggled Thursday to determine why a jetliner raced down a runway before crashing in a fireball that killed at least 189 people — an accident that set off a fierce debate over whether to close Brazil's busiest airport.

Security video released by the air force showed TAM Flight 3054 from Porto Alegre speeding down the tarmac more than four times as fast as other planes landing around the same time.

The Airbus-320 skidded off the main runway in a heavy rain, jumped over a highway and slammed into a building Tuesday night, killing all 186 people aboard and at least three people on the ground.

It was Brazil's worst air disaster and the worst anywhere involving an Airbus A-320, according to the aviation analysis Web site airsafe.com.

Brig. Jose Carlos Pereira, president of the national airport authority Infraero, said Thursday he was perplexed by the video. "An airplane doesn't speed up by a miracle. Something happened after it touched down," Pereira said. "He landed normally, the images show that was the case."

Brazilian aviation consultant Elias Gedeon said it was too early to blame the pilot: "The bottom line is we don't know what happened. Why was he going so fast? He couldn't stop. Was it the water on the runway? Was it his ability? We don't know."

The Congonhas airport recently resurfaced its runway to provide better braking in rainy conditions. But the new surface hadn't dried enough for the next step: cutting deep grooves into the tarmac that allow water to run off the runway and provide increased grip.

'Complete renovation' sought
Federal prosecutors asked a federal judge to "temporarily paralyze" Congonhas Airport — a move that could disrupt air travel across Latin America's largest nation — "until a complete renovation of both of its runways can be completed and there is certainty that they are fully secure for full operation."

Just four miles from the center of Latin America's largest city, Congonhas offers convenience for domestic passengers, despite concerns about its proximity to densely populated areas and the safety of short runways that end just before a major highway.

"This airport is too convenient not to be used," said Vivianne Santorini, a 57-year-old attorney waiting to check in for a flight to the central city of Belo Horizonte. "Is it safe? I guess not. But there are also risks driving you car and crossing the street and everybody continues driving their car and crossing the street."

Leonardo Mota Netto, chief spokesman for Infraero, said closing the airport was not realistic.

"To close down Congonhas, to do it correctly, would take at least 15 years," Mota said. "That is the time needed to build viable alternatives, new airports, and redirect flights to other airports in the region which will also have to undergo improvements in their infrastructure."

Mota said that about 18 million people pass through Congonhas each year. The airport, built in 1936 on what were then the city's outskirts, is designed to handle 12 million.

He said airlines and the public have resisted moves to limit flights at Congonhas and Brazil needs more airports, not fewer, with the number of air passengers growing at a rate of around 16 percent a year.

The alternatives, at least in the short run, appear to be few.

Sao Paulo's international airport in Guarulhos lies 22 miles from the city center through dense traffic-clogged streets and doesn't have enough capacity to add all the flights that pass through Congonhas.

Aviation officials insist that Congonhas' 6,362-foot runway is safe, but pilots have complained about slippery conditions when wet and the small margin of error.

In 1996, a TAM Airlines Fokker-100 crashed into nearby houses shortly after takeoff, killing all 96 aboard and six on the ground.

MORE FROM AMERICAS

Americas Section Front

Cartel’s revenge escalates Mexico drug war   Honduran interim leader may step down Newsweek: Outrage over Honduras smacks of hypocrisy U.S. set to boost military role in Colombia   2 missing boys found in Bahamas Tropical Storm Dolores forms; Carlos weakens Tot survives 8-mile river ride on toy Americas Section Front   Add Americas headlines to your news reader: