Skip navigation
sponsored by 

Belmont will prove to be lady's day

Rags to Riches will be first filly to win race in 102 years

Gary I Rothstein / EPA
Rags to Riches will surprise the colts to win the Belmont Stakes, MSNBC.com's Mike Brunker writes.
Slide show
Exercise rider Michelle Nevin and a groom walk Triple Crown hopeful Big Brown in the paddock before the 140th running of the Belmont Stakes horse race at Belmont Park in Elmont, New York
  No crown for Big Brown
Big Brown fails to capture Triple Crown as long shot Da' Tara goes on to win the 140th running of the Belmont Stakes

more photos

Special feature
SECRETARIAT TURCOTTE
Triple Crown winners
Only 11 horses have won the Kentucky Derby, Preakness Stakes and Belmont Stakes in the same year.

NBCSports.com

  Join the Debate
Frank Perez, Hey Byrne

NBC recently held a panel discussion on Eight Belles' tragic breakdown and other controversies currently swirling around the horse racing industry. Click on the links below to hear expert opinions and share your own thoughts.

By Mike Brunker
Horse racing editor
NBCSports.com
updated 4:38 a.m. ET June 8, 2007

Mike Brunker
Horse racing editor

E-mail
With Kentucky Derby winner Street Sense on the sidelines, the 139th Belmont Stakes initially looked as though it would simply be a coronation of Preakness winner Curlin. But that was before The Queen signed up for Saturday’s race.

Rags to Riches, who will seek to become the first 3-year-old filly to win the Test of a Champion in 102 years, turned what could have been a lackluster renewal of the 1 ½-mile third leg of the Triple Crown into a palace intrigue. Not only is she hoping to knife Curlin in the back, she will simultaneously have to prevent Hard Spun, the scheming would-be usurper, from spoiling her ascension to the throne.

Even before sitting down to handicap the race, all horseplayers should tip our fedoras to Rags to Riches’ owners Derrick Smith and Michael Tabor for saving us from a third straight meaningless Belmont Stakes. And while we’re at it, let’s thrust our cigars skyward for trainer Todd Pletcher, who will attempt to break his 0-for-28 winless streak in Triple Crown races with a Bronx cheer at racing history.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement

But will we be cheering these same worthies after the race?

You have to flip through a lot of pages in the New York Racing Association press guide to get to the last filly to win the Belmont Stakes, the longest and most grueling of the three Triple Crown races. The answer to that particular trivia question is Tanya, who knee-capped six rivals to win the 1905 Belmont by half a length.

But take a closer look at that chart and you’ll see that the race was contested at 1 ¼ miles that year — not the current  distance of 1 ½ miles — and read the chart footnotes, where it says that after opening a three-length lead in the stretch, Tanya was “finishing flagging … and just lasted the journey.”

That means the only 3-year-old female to win the race at the current distance or beyond is the aptly named Ruthless, who beat three male rivals to capture the inaugural running of the then-1 5/8 mile Belmont Stakes by a head in 1867, collecting a king’s ransom of $1,850 for her efforts.

Slide show
Image: Week in Sports Pictures
  Week in Sports
Tennis swings, cattle wrestlers, a family golf celebration, and more

more photos

Only 10 fillies have tested the males since Tanya’s victory, but optimists will note that four have hit the board – Flying Fairy (third in 1913); Flambino (third in 1927); Genuine Risk (second in 1980) and My Flag (third in 1996). But there also is less there than meets the eye: Flying Fairy was third in a field of just four horses and Flambino was third in a field of six.

Genuine Risk ran a truly great race, grabbing the lead in the stretch before surrendering it to Temperance Hill.  My Flag closed well for the show but never threatened.

Silverbulletday was the last uppity filly to even try the boys, finishing seventh in 1999.

All of which is a long-winded way of pointing out that even though Rags to Riches enters the race off four straight victories, three of them in Grade 1 stakes races, she is up against history on Saturday.

But then I’ve always had a soft spot for the ladies, which is why I think the 3-1 third choice in the seven-horse field can upset the apple cart of the ages and beat Curlin on Saturday.


Sponsored links