Skip navigation

Surprise! Hot, young celeb gets her way

Paris' early release sets horrible precedent for future celebrity violators

MSNBC video
Paris Hilton out of jail
June 7: Paris Hilton has been reassigned from jail to 40 days house arrest. Susan Filan, Courtney Hazlett and Michael Musto talk about the new developments.

MSNBC

  Celebrity video
Singer’s school fosters kids’ love of arts
Nov. 15: He left his heart in San Francisco, but Tony Bennett is making a difference back in his old neighborhood, giving students a chance to embrace their passions. NBC’s Lester Holt reports.

Slideshow
Image: Elizabeth Hurley
  Best and worst celebrity fashions of 2009
From glamorous gowns to stylish suits to complete fashion failures, a look at the year so far.

more photos

COMMENTARY
By Michael Ventre
msnbc.com contributor
updated 3:07 p.m. ET June 7, 2007

If Johnny The Fence, doing a stretch of two to five years, wants to get out of the stir, all he has to do is claim that his back hurts and he can no longer endure the strain of prison life.

If Dave the Meth Dealer, scheduled to be incarcerated for the next five years, doesn’t like spending his days behind bars, he can just call for the doctor and say he’s having migraines and needs to be home in his own bed.

Worse, if Lance the TV Star gets a couple of DUIs and can’t quite cope without his hot tub and his Porsche, all he has to do is hire a high-powered attorney who specializes in helping the rich and famous avoid responsibility.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

Which brings us to Paris Hilton, up until Thursday the most famous prison inmate in the country. But authorities have decided that, after “extensive consultation with Los Angeles County medical personnel,” she is finished with her sentence after just five days, and will now serve the rest of her time at home, wearing an ankle bracelet.

No word yet on whether Paris will be free to roam wherever she wants until a custom-made, diamond-studded ankle bracelet is delivered by Tiffany’s, but you know that’s coming.

I’m no legal expert, but I know enough as a private citizen to understand the importance of precedent. And this sets a horrible precedent.

Paris Hilton jail saga
Tabloids pass on Paris?
July 2:  Hilton fatigue is underway among America’s favorite tabloids.  Paris Hilton overload has caused “US Weekly” to deliberately leave Paris out of this week’s issue.  VH1’s Paul F. Tompkins responds to the magazine’s decision. 

Paris Hilton had already been coddled beyond belief. She had been sentenced to 45 days in prison for violating the terms of her probation on an alcohol-related reckless driving case. She didn’t get it. She reasoned that just because the law requires a person to spend time in jail if they don’t comply with the terms of her probation doesn’t mean she can’t drive around without a suspended license.

Then when she appeared before a judge, she claimed she didn’t know, that she was told by her publicist, Elliot Mintz, that it was all right to drive around under those circumstances. Then she fired her publicist before hiring him right back.

Then she whined about how unfair it all was. Her quote: “I feel I was treated unfairly and that the sentence is both cruel and unwarranted. I don’t deserve this.” She neglected to mention how cruel it would have been had she killed somebody while driving under the influence.

Her mother, Kathy Hilton, otherwise known as “The Enabler,” called her original 45-day sentence “pathetic and disgusting, a waste of taxpayers’ money” and “It is a joke.”

Then some of her friends suggested going to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger to seek a pardon. One of them even wrote Arnold a letter, claiming Hilton should go free because “she provides beauty and excitement to most of our mundane lives.” I don’t know if it’s possible for a governor to veto a letter, but Arnold should have looked into it in this case.

Slideshow
Image: Jermaine Dupri & Pascal Mouawad's Nu Pop Movement Los Angeles Launch Party
  The Week in Celebrity Sightings
Affleck and Garner play ball, Paris struts one last time, ‘Idols’ rock New York and more.

more photos

That fan letter also claimed this: “She provides hope for young people all over the U.S. and the world.” I’m sure she does now that she managed to weasel out of a 45-day jail sentence after just five days. I’m sure there are guys on death row who think anything’s possible now.

Paris Hilton was originally scheduled to serve 45 days in prison. Almost immediately, it was cut down to 23 days because of a good-behavior discount credited in advance. And now, after five days and several reports from bloggers and gossip sites that she cried a few times and didn’t like the accommodations, she was allowed to go home.

I know it sounds incredibly naïve, but what kind of a message does this send?


Sponsored links

Resource guide