Skip navigation
advertisement

‘Grey’s’ spinoff shows familiar potential

Despite clunky tie-in to main show, new series could become its own hit

Image: Kate Walsh
ABC file
Dr. Addison Montgomery (Kate Walsh) is ready to leave Seattle Grace for sunny Santa Monica.
  Television video
  ‘Jersey Shore’ cast on controversy
Dec. 18: Snooki, Pauly D and The Situation about the controversy surrounding the show's use the of the word "guido."

COMMENTARY
By Andy Dehnart
msnbc.com contributor
updated 8:16 p.m. ET May 7, 2007

“Anybody seen Addison?”

That’s what Mark “McSteamy” Sloan asked chief Richard Webber early in the special two-hour episode of “Grey’s Anatomy,” which served as both a regular episode and the pilot for a new spinoff series that will be led by Addison Montgomery.

“She’s gone. She took a leave of absence,” the chief said flatly, adding that the character first introduced in the final episode of the first season “didn’t give a reason.” McSteamy asked, “Did she tell you where she was going?”

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

“All she said was, she needed some time — to be happy and free, if I recall correctly,” the chief said, moving on.

That is how “Grey’s Anatomy” opened the door to get rid of one of its main characters: unconvincingly. The surprise was that despite this abrupt and thin explanation for both Addison’s disappearance and the parallel story, the new show actually worked.

To introduce “Grey’s Anatomy’s” audience to the new series, the show’s writers and producers decided to intertwine the two new shows, rather than send Addison off for her own hour-long adventure. What remained were two separate episodes that were fused together, with only occasional links between them.

The transitions between the two were sharp and abrupt, making both episodes seem longer than they actually were. And without establishing shots illustrating the shift in location from Seattle to Los Angeles, the two shows were simultaneously conflated and disconnected.

Only well into the story did the “Grey’s” half bother to offer a more substantive explanation for Addison’s absence, which apparently came as the result of a falling out with Alex and her continued detachment from her ex-lover. At one point McSteamy told Alex, “Whatever you didn’t do sent Addison running for the hills.”

Her excuse for running away and visiting her friends was different. “I want to have a baby,” Addison told Naomi, a friend from medical school who now runs the Oceanside Wellness Group with her ex-husband (Jackson, played by Taye Diggs) and a band of doctors with their own issues. But that was ultimately only an excuse; later, Naomi told Addison, “there is no fertility potential here.”

But there still was potential for the series, in part because “Private Practice” (the spin-off’s tentative name) isn’t entirely different from “Grey’s Anatomy.” It had the same moments of craziness and crisis; the same jaunty, light, happy, staccato music; the same locations, from stairways to elevators to hospital operating rooms; the same hook-ups and tragedies; and the same quirkiness that its parent demonstrates regularly.

The office that houses Oceanside appears to be more alive than Seattle Grace Hospital. Brighter colors fill the walls instead of flat grays, and the decor is more modern, mostly because they’re an office, not a hospital. In addition, the backdrop of Southern California offers more obviously warm exterior locations.

Yet the new series does not seem to have shifted much in tone, and since “Grey’s Anatomy” tends to combine (melo)drama with moments of comedy and tension, so did “Private Practice.”

Also like its parent, the new show also has a cast of strong actors, although unlike “Grey’s,” many aren’t starting the new series as relative unknowns. From Tim Daly to Amy Brenneman, “Alias”’ Merrin Dungey to “Prison Break’s” Paul Adelstein, they’re either show leads or character actors seeking refuge from other shows.

Even in their early moments together, they had strong chemistry, appearing to be likeable and engaging. None, however, have had the chance to grow into their characters and to explore their quirks and personalities. The characters that were the most developed, ironically enough, were the disposable, episode-specific ones, such as the surrogate mother — whose life Addison saved in an operating room, echoing “Grey’s Anatomy” — and the group of men who might have been the baby’s father.


Sponsored links

Resource guide