Bands critics love to hate keep cashing in

updated 5:34 p.m. ET March 21, 2007

NEW YORK - Few bands inspire such intense hatred as Nickelback.

The post-grunge Canadian quartet has been trashed, bashed and hated on by countless critics, music snobs and other like-minded souls. So have much-maligned acts like Hinder, a rock band from Oklahoma; the Grammy-winning Black Eyed Peas, who have spawned infectious rap hits “My Humps” and “Don’t Phunk With My Heart”; and Britney Spears, who in her heyday ruled radio but was condemned for everything from her voice to not writing her own songs.

Yet these acts have sold millions upon millions of albums. So are the critics wrong? Do music buyers have bad taste? Is this karmic payback to all the haters?

“There are some bands that, let’s face it, are critic-proof,” said Nathan Brackett, a senior editor at Rolling Stone. “Just like there are some movies that are critic-proof. Nobody is really reading the reviews for ‘Norbit,’ you know? And nobody’s reading Nickelback reviews either.”

Slide show   The week in celebrity sightings Jessica and Tony share a night out; Pam joins ‘Big Brother Australia,’; Bon Jovi rocks Central Park. more photos

That might be a good thing. Nickelback’s “All the Right Reasons,” which debuted at No. 1 on the charts in fall 2005 and was still No. 16 this week, was called “hard-rock ridiculousness” by The New York Times and “unspeakably awful” by Allmusic.com. Even the late Nirvana frontman and grunge icon Kurt Cobain would disapprove, suggested Rolling Stone, which called the disc “so depressing, you’re almost glad Kurt’s not around to hear it.”

Young people who “are introduced to these bands on the radio, they don’t have a lot of baggage,” Brackett said. “A lot of kids don’t care if an act, you know, kind of took their guitar sound from some other band.”

Post-grunge outfits like Nickelback and Hinder continue to be popular — or wreak havoc, whatever your opinion — in part because they appeal to the estrogen set, said Craig Marks, editor in chief of Blender magazine. A “slightly hipper band” will sell more albums to guys than girls, he said.

“They’re selling a lot of records to very casual music fans who don’t buy a lot of CDs,” Marks said. “When you’re selling 5 million albums like Nickelback or 2½ million like Hinder, and especially when you’re making your mark with big ballads that are kind of wedding songs, then you’re selling records to both males and females. And that’s often how you get from selling 1½
million records to selling 4 or 5 million records.”

When “teenage girls or tween girls like an artist, that’s often a sign that ... the artist isn’t cool,” said Marks, who also gives Spears as an example. “You know, ‘My little sister likes them.’ ”

MORE FROM MUSIC

Music Section Front

Black Kids are all right with blog buzz New Orleans trumpeter still playing gigs at 97 Mellencamp calls himself an ‘ex-rock star’ Scott Storch’s career freefall came fast, hard Mamma Mia! ABBA fans love soundtrack Band singer Jo Stafford dies at 90 Jonas Brothers thrilled by Coldplay shout-out He ain't heavy... Italy's metal brother 9 music acts that are no longer alternative Send us your summer concert photos Music Section Front   Add Music headlines to your news reader: