Hotmail
Messenger
My MSN
MSN Directory
Ariz. to still allow racist images on trucks
Lawmakers reject ban on splash guards with offensive terms, pictures
 | Slide show |
 | Martin Luther King Jr. See the civil rights leader in speeches and marches from Alabama to Washington. more photos |
Stand and be counted |
In the year of Barack Obama, there is much discussion of the state of race relations in America. But many other race-related topics are barely being discussed. Read NBC Senior Vice President Mark Whitaker's essay on the subject and then tell us what's going on in your town or community. |
 | Video: Race & ethnicity |
 Grads of segregated class reflect on Obama's candidacy July 23: Barack Obama's presidential race gives 1958 graduates of the Washington High School in Pensacola, a chance to reflect on their segregated past. NBC's Michael Okwu reports. |
 | The Big Picture |
 | (broadband only) |
PHOENIX - It's still going to be legal in Arizona for trucks to have splash guards with racist terms and silhouettes of naked women.
The House on Thursday rejected a Democratic amendment that would have banned splash guards with "images that are obscene or hateful."
The amendment's sponsor, Rep. Ed Ableser of Tempe, said he'd seen a splash guard that used the word "pickaninny" — a derogatory term for black children — and said his proposal was intended "to make sure those individuals that have hateful motives don't express or push those images upon others in our communities."
Rep. Theresa Ulmer, D-Yuma, supported the amendment and said it fit with lawmakers' other efforts to crack down on pornography and sexual predators.
"I personally am tired of explaining to my 11-year-old son why they (women) are depicted on mud flaps, but not all women are 36Ds. He's very confused by that," Ulmer said. "But seriously, this is about family values — what are we going to send out as a message to our children."
No law on 'hateful'
Rep. Andy Biggs, R-Gilbert, opposed the amendment, saying it probably violated First Amendment protections for free speech and that "hateful" isn't defined by law.
Democratic Rep. Ben Miranda of Phoenix voted for the amendment but said he did so only because he felt compelled to do so because a vote against it could be misconstrued.
Click for related content |
The amendment, Miranda said, would "stretch the Constitution today beyond limits that it was ever intended to be stretched."
Rep. Kyrsten Sinema, D-Phoenix, said the First Amendment "is a wonderful and broad amendment" but courts have ruled that obscene items aren't protected.
Ableser's amendment, rejected on a 19-31 roll call vote, would have been added to a bill (HB2316) sought by the Arizona Trucking Association to change Arizona's height requirement for rear fender splash guards. The bill was given preliminary approval and now awaits a formal House vote.
- Discuss Story On Newsvine
- Rate Story:
View popularLowHigh - Instant Message
MORE FROM RACE & ETHNICITY |
 Race & ethnicity Section Front |
| Add Race & ethnicity headlines to your news reader: |
Sponsored links
Resource guide