Lockheed Martin to build future moonship

Winners and losers
All 10 of NASA's centers will be involved in the Orion project. Lockheed Martin's corporate partners in the development effort include Aerojet, Hamilton Sundstrand, Honeywell and Orbital Sciences as well as United Space Alliance, which is the prime contractor for the space shuttle program.

""We are honored by the trust that NASA has placed in the Lockheed Martin team for this historic and vital step forward in human space exploration," Bob Stevens, Lockheed Martin's chairman of the board, president and chief executive officer, said in a written statement. "Our entire team is fully committed to supporting NASA as we join together to help make the vision for space exploration a reality."

In March, Lockheed Martin said it would have 2,400 employees working on the Orion project. Half of them would be based in Houston, near NASA's Johnson Space Center, where much of the engineering work would be done. The other half would be spread out at NASA sites in Louisiana, Alabama, Mississippi and Florida. Final assembly of the Orion vehicle would take place at NASA's Kennedy Space Center in Florida.

In the wake of Thursday's announcement, Northrop Grumman said it was still hoping to win a role in some other aspect of the Constellation program. "We're disappointed, obviously, and we're looking forward to moving on to the next part of exploration," Northrop Grumman spokesman Brooks McKinney told MSNBC.com.

NASA's Horowitz noted that other pieces of Project Constellation were yet to be put out for bid, including the lunar lander, the earth departure stage and the heavy-lift launch vehicle. "Orion is one element of what Constellation has to accomplish. ... There are tremendous opportunities in the future," he said.

Hanley told MSNBC.com that the heavy-lift launcher would likely be the next major component to go out for bidding.

Critics galore
Project Constellation already has plenty of critics: Some say it's not worth tens of billions of dollars to retrace Apollo's steps to the moon, while others say the program is structured to follow an "old space" business model that virtually ensures cost overruns.

The two teams that competed for the Orion program were led by aerospace giants well-known to NASA, rather than "new space" entrepreneurs. Boeing has been the prime U.S. contractor for the space station, while Boeing and Lockheed Martin are partners in the United Space Alliance. Lockheed Martin was the prime contractor the last time NASA tried to have a shuttle successor built, but its $1.3 billion X-33 project ended in failure five years ago.

"New space" consultant Charles Lurio told MSNBC.com in advance of Thursday's announcement that it would be a "mind-numbingly irrelevant event."

"It follows the same pattern of high-cost development that was fine for Apollo but has not created anything affordable or sustainable," Lurio said.

Among the other concerns raised recently:

• In a report last month, the Government Accountability Office counseled NASA to commit funds only to the preliminary design phase of the Orion project (PDF file). The GAO said that the space agency should go slow until it came up with more precise requirements and more realistic cost estimates.
• Space scientists have complained that the back-to-the-moon effort was sucking hundreds of millions of dollars away from other areas of the NASA budget. During a congressional hearing earlier this year, Wesley Huntress, a former NASA executive who is now at the Carnegie Institution of Washington, said the effort was less like Apollo on steroids and more like "Apollo on food stamps."
• The Space Frontier Foundation, an advocacy group for "new space" ventures, called on NASA to shift billions of dollars away from the Orion project and instead beef up the Commercial Orbital Transportation Services program, which has set aside $500 million for an entrepreneurial approach to resupplying the space station.

This month, NASA split that $500 million between two fledgling aerospace companies, California-based SpaceX and Oklahoma-based Rocketplane Kistler. In contrast to NASA's traditional "cost-plus" contractual arrangements, those two companies will be paid incrementally as they reach milestones leading up to demonstration flights in 2009.

If the COTS program is successful, another competition will be conducted, with the winners being given contracts to transfer crew and cargo between Earth and the space station in the post-2010 period — taking over from the space shuttle fleet. This two-track approach to NASA's future spaceflight needs could raise the prospect of future competition between the COTS winners and Lockheed Martin.

More future missions
Hanley said he hoped COTS was successful — because NASA would prefer not to use the costlier, more capable Orion crew exploration vehicle, or CEV, to resupply the space station. "The CEV is being designed to go to the moon and other parts beyond low Earth orbit. So in that respect ... the CEV's way overdesigned to do an ISS mission," he said.

Slideshow   Month in space: Future frontiers Click to see images of Hubble's revival and other outer-space highlights from 2009. more photos

Elon Musk, founder and chief executive officer of SpaceX, agreed with that analysis. He said using the Orion to service the space station would be like using a Mack truck for jobs better-suited to a light pickup truck. In Musk's view, the "pickup trucks" would include SpaceX's Dragon spaceship.

"We're very confident that we will be able to relieve Orion of the burden of servicing the space station," Musk told MSNBC.com.

That's not to say that the Orion would be used exclusively for moon missions. Hanley said the Orion could play a role in more ambitious trips as well, including flights to Mars and asteroids.

"We hope to do any number of missions that people haven't even thought of yet ... This is the system for the next generation," he said.

MORE FROM HUMAN SPACEFLIGHT

Human Spaceflight Section Front

Trio brings holiday cheer to space station Space station trio lands safely in Kazakhstan Astronauts land with families on their minds New dad-in-space: Focusing on shuttle job easy Plan for human mission to asteroid gains speed Countdown begins for NASA's uncertain future Space hotel says it's on schedule to open in 2012 Space clown comes back down to Earth Astronaut hopefuls don’t mind being ‘Chumps’ Top 10 antics in outer space Human Spaceflight Section Front   Add Human Spaceflight headlines to your news reader: