Skip navigation

Witherspoon has the Oscar momentum

But could Felicity Huffman sneak up and take the prize on Oscar night?

Reese Witherspoon
Suzanne Tenner / 20th Century Fox via Reuters
Reese Witherspoon received a best actress nomination for her role as June Carter in "Walk the Line."
INTERACTIVE
The nominees
Vote for your favorites in the top five Academy Award categories.
COMMENTARY
By John Hartl
Film critic
msnbc.com
updated 3:09 p.m. ET Feb. 21, 2006

Two former winners and three first-time nominees are competing for best actress in the current Academy Awards race. And it looks like one of the newcomers, Reese Witherspoon, has the edge over former winners Judi Dench and Charlize Theron.

In “Walk the Line,” Witherspoon plays country singer June Carter, who eventually added “Cash” to her name when she married Johnny Cash, played by Joaquin Phoenix. Both actors did their own singing, impressing critics as well as Academy voters with their ability to sound like the singers they’re playing.

Sissy Spacek did much the same thing with her impersonation of Loretta Lynn, winning the best actress Oscar for “Coal Miner’s Daughter” a quarter of a century ago. Spacek made such an impression in her earlier films (“Badlands,” “Carrie”) that her Oscar win carried an unmistakable it’s-about-time factor.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement | your ad here

The same kind of momentum may help Witherspoon, who should have been nominated for her 1999 breakthrough role in “Election,” as a ruthless Nebraska high-school politician matching wits with a schoolteacher.

Consistently busy since since her attention-getting debut in “The Man in the Moon” (1991), she was especially effective in “Freeway” (1996), as a seductive teenager who hitches a ride with an unbalanced psychiatrist, and in “Pleasantville” (1998), as a high-school kid trapped in a 1950s television show. “Cruel Intentions” (1999) didn’t quite work as a contemporary version of “Dangerous Liaisons,” but the star was her future husband, Ryan Phillippe.

Witherspoon demonstrated her box-office potential with the featherweight comedies, “Legally Blonde” (2001) and “Sweet Home Alabama” (2002), and earned respect if not the greatest notices for trying to resurrect “Vanity Fair” (2004) and “The Importance of Being Earnest”  (2002) — in which she co-starred with Dench.

Don’t count out Dame Dench
Judi Dench
Yui Mok / AP
Judi Dench is nominated for the title role in "Mrs Henderson Presents."

Dench was a hit with art-house audiences last year in both “Ladies in Lavender” and “Mrs. Henderson Presents,” two World War II stories in which she co-starred with another celebrated British actor: Maggie Smith in the first film, Bob Hoskins in the latter. She was also a memorable Lady Catherine de Bourg in “Pride and Prejudice.”

But the nomination was bestowed for her performance as the widowed Laura Henderson in Stephen Frears’ “Mrs. Henderson Presents,” a fact-based story about a theater owner who introduces “artistic” nudity while facing declining audiences during the blitz. In almost any other year, Dench be a contender for her sly performance as a pragmatic woman whose motive turns out to be linked to the previous world war.

What’s likely to keep her from taking home the prize is the fact that she’s a fairly recent Oscar winner in the supporting category, for her brief appearance as Queen Elizabeth in “Shakespeare in Love” (1998). She was even better as Queen Victoria in “Mrs. Brown” (1997), which earned Dench her first nomination for best actress.

A late bloomer who spent her early years on the stage, she was also nominated for “Chocolat” (2000) and “Iris” (2001), in which she played the novelist Iris Murdoch. During the past decade, she reached the largest audiences of her career by taking on the role of “M” in the James Bond movies starring Pierce Brosnan. She’s set to play the role again in “Casino Royale.”

Theron: More than a one-hit wonder
Charlize Theron
Vince Bucci / Getty Images
Charlize Theron is nominated for her role as Josey Aimees in "North Country"

Charlize Theron is even less likely than Dench to pick up a second Oscar; she took home the best-actress award just two years ago for “Monster.” Her remarkable physical makeover made it easy to accept her as serial killer Aileen Wuoronos. She looks more like her old self in “North Country,” playing a single mother who battles brutal male chauvinism when she works at a mine.

The fact-based script is full of strong moments for Theron, who gets considerable help from Frances McDormand as her frightened co-worker (she’s nominated for best supporting actress) and Sissy Spacek and Richard Jenkins as her parents. But the movie itself is not as challenging as “Monster,” the competition is fierce, so it looks she’ll make do with the nomination this time.

Still, a second nomination from the Academy calls attention to the fact that this South African actress is not a one-hit wonder. She’s a better actress than many critics conceded even when “Monster” came out. Her spirited performances in “The Cider House Rules” (1999), “2 Days in the Valley” (1996) and “The Life and Death of Peter Sellers” (2004) deserve another look.


Sponsored links

Resource guide