Skip navigation
sponsored by 

TV favorites rewarded, if miscategorized

‘Housewives’ is no comedy, but Globes mostly got it right

Kevin Winter / Getty Images
"Desperate Housewives" won the Golden Globes best TV comedy award, but many question why it's being considered a comedy at all.
COMMENTARY
By Andy Dehnart
MSNBC contributor
updated 12:29 a.m. ET Jan. 17, 2006

Right before Mary-Louise Parker won a Golden Globe for best actress in a comedy, presenter Chris Rock made fun of the fact that, in her category, she was nominated alongside all four of ABC’s housewives. “Desperate Housewives is one of the biggest shows on the planet, and ‘Weeds’ is only watched by Snoop Doggy Dogg,” he said.

With just under 1.5 million viewers for its first episode, “Weeds” was barely noticeable among the flourishing green grass that is “Desperate Housewives,” which had nearly 22 million viewers for its first episode alone. Still, “Weeds” is a compelling series, achingly funny and heartbreakingly desperate all at once, and in their sophomore season, the four housewives had far weaker material to work with than they did their first season. Thus, Parker won for her performance in “Weeds,” Showtime’s single-camera, half-hour dramatic comedy that debuted last August.

The housewives may have been the favorites — just in terms of numerical odds, they certainly were — but this is what viewers expect from the TV half of the Golden Globes: upsets from the underdogs, and awards for fan favorites that may not be watched by the masses. Besides, “Desperate Housewives” got its revenge later.

Story continues below ↓
advertisement

The Golden Globes look like an awards show you and your friends could produce in the local Holiday Inn ballroom with a budget of about a thousand dollars. The statues themselves are unimpressive, statues that are reminiscent of little league trophies with their fake marble bases and plastic gold-painted tops. Even the celebrities treat it lightly. “It’s lovely to be here, and at least it’s, you know, no effort,” Emma Thompson said.

This folksy, have-fun attitude can be charming, and it’s definitely a welcome break from January’s onslaught of overproduced awards shows that offer hollow recognition. Unlike those award shows that have to tell the celebrities they’ve won just so they’ll bother to show up, The Golden Globes tends to attract all the nominees in each category. The winners are often unpredictable, and every strong performance and well-produced show or film has a shot. Considering that the Hollywood Foreign Press Association has fewer than 100 members, the unpredictability makes perfect sense.

In part because of this perceived hipness, the Globes are given lots of weight in Hollywood, frequently viewed as predictors of Oscar nominations; perhaps they even influence Academy members as they cast their ballots.

Slide show
  Satin and lace
Stars light up the red carpet with glamorous fashions at the Golden Globes
The Golden Globes awarded for television series, however, don’t have the same authority, even though they tend to recognize critically acclaimed and viewer-worshiped series.

Awards that are ahead of the curve
Unlike the Emmys, the Globes usually aren’t five years behind (how many years after “Frasier” became a comedy black hole did the Emmys keep flowing just because “Frasier” was familiar?) And the Globes tend to be more connected to the pulse of America.

That’s not to say the shows with the highest ratings take all the awards; in fact, the Globes tend to be ahead of the curve, awarding series such as “The Shield” and “Nip/Tuck” even though they might not have the ratings of “CSI” or “American Idol.”

This year, the television acting awards went to series that aren’t breakthrough smash hits, but that have solid ratings and passionate fans. Besides Parker’s award for “Weeds,” Sandra Oh’s performance in “Grey’s Anatomy” and Hugh Laurie’s performance in “House” were both recognized. Both actors play characters that are the life at the center of their respective shows. Likewise, former “Daily Show” cast member Steve Carell won for his performance as the maddeningly annoying boss in NBC’s “The Office.”

All of those series are in their first or second years, as was every television show that won this year, continuing the Golden Globes’ tradition of consistently recognizing new shows. Every year for the past eight years, the Hollywood Foreign Press Association has honored a different drama; this year, the Golden Globe went to ABC’s popular “Lost.”


Sponsored links

Resource guide

Get Your 2008 Credit Score

Search Jobs

Find your next car

Find Your Dream Home

Find a business to start

$7 trades, no fee IRAs