N. Korea cuts off U.N. food, ignites famine fears

Strings attached
And it is unclear whether the needs of high-risk populations targeted by the WFP will be met. In its largest humanitarian effort ever, WFP has been running 19 factories employing about 2,000 Korean women to produce enriched noodles and biscuits for about 6.5 million people in high-risk groups, including small children and pregnant and nursing mothers. In all, it has delivered nearly 4 million tons of food to North Koreans since 1995. It also has had 40 to 50 staff members in the country and offices outside the capital to ensure that products reached the most needy.

"If you give the food through the WFP, it is more likely to reach vulnerable people," said Noland. "If you give the food to the North Korean government, it will distribute according to its own preferences, which are basically political."

Since the regime's priority appears to be its own survival, experts say, it will naturally favor loyal military and political elite, rather than the most needy.

The move to eject WFP may be a Faustian gamble for more help from its neighbors, said Robert Dujarric, a North Asia expert and visiting scholar at Japan's Research Institute of Economy, Trade and Industry. "They may be hoping that they can get enough aid from Korea and China, which comes with fewer strings attached."

Or it may be a ploy to get the WFP to relax rules for its aid. Even though the organization's plants and satellite offices were shut down by mid-December, a WFP staff member confirmed Thursday that WFP is still in talks with donors to reformulate the program in a way acceptable both to Pyongyang and to major donors — primarily the United States, Japan and South Korea. While donor nations insisted on extensive monitoring, Pyongyang is insisting that the WFP operation be scaled back to a skeletal staff with no field offices, essentially making dependable monitoring impossible.

Giving food aid without the monitoring would be a mistake, says Clark Sorenson, a professor of Korean Studies at University of Washington. "From my point of view, what the international community needs to do is avoid supporting the public distribution system, because it just reinforces the power of (Kim Jong Il's) Korean Workers Party and the political elite," he said.

Reverse on reform
Longer term, the ban on private grain sales bodes badly for production. For the last few years, after meeting obligations to the state, North Korean farmers have been allowed to use or sell excess grain on the free market. But that incentive to farmers will disappear in the next growing season.

The limited free market experiment was modeled after China’s free market reforms of the late 1970s, which ultimately launched that country's economic boom. In North Korea the reforms were barely in their infancy, but analysts say they were beginning to help people supplement meager rations.

"(The government) may be concerned with control issues when it comes to the market," said Dujarric. "And obviously to them politics has priority over feeding the people."

The disappearance of the incentive could prompt the farmers to resort to strategies used in other desperate times — secretly growing crops up on the hillsides, cutting, hiding and hoarding grain before harvest time — or simply cutting production.

It will be difficult to track how it plays out on the ground. Without the presence of the WFP, North Korea will become that much more opaque to the outside world. The program's monitors have long been the main conduit for information on the insular nation, particularly the situation in the countryside, which is largely off limits to foreigners.

“We are heading back toward a situation like in the 1990s in which you are foreclosing the mechanisms by which people actually access food,” said Noland. “At the same time you are shutting off information.”

In the last crisis, by the time the world understood the severity of the famine, and Pyongyang finally called for international food aid, it was too late for hundreds of thousands of its citizens.

MORE FROM ASIA-PACIFIC

Asia-Pacific Section Front

Verdict for Chinese dissident due Friday Uighurs told U.N. of fears of return to China China blasts claim it 'hijacked' climate talks Experts: ‘Rumbling’ volcano may blow up soon Ex-conjoined twins leave hospital for birthday Chinese man gets 12 years for killing rare tiger UK officials: China sets execution date for Briton Verdict for Chinese dissident due Friday Major earthquake strikes Taiwan; 14 injured Reports: Malaysia fighter jet engine stolen Asia-Pacific Section Front   Add Asia-Pacific headlines to your news reader: